Find 2 Star Hotels in Mattituck, NY from AED79

"After our hotel cancelled on us last minute, we rerouted to the Bentley Hotel. I’m glad we did. Staff were friendly, room was huge and grounds were well maintained. My family had a great Father’s Day weekend at this hotel. "

"clean"

"Overall, this was a very good experience. The room was clean, including the bed and the bathroom. Everything worked as expected, and there was plenty of hot water for showering. The TV and the WiFi worked well. It felt safe. The property is convenient to all mid-shoreline activities. It was very quiet except for one instance in which there was a family with an exuberant toddler staying in the room right above me; I notified the desk person and he took care of it right away. It's a good budget...

"We enjoyed our stay and felt it was good value for the area. "

"Staff was friendly"

"This was a great location for my weekend of activities. The room was clean and had all amenities I needed. "

"The hotel was bohemian chic! We loved the character of the hotel, from the design aspects, plants, delish cold fruit filled water waiting in the lobby and pool area! We had a great time! Truly relaxing! We walked everywhere! It was centrally located and had easy access to all the local eateries. I will definitely stay again!!!"

"Great location"

"Was decent. Staff let me check in 2 hours early which was super considerate. They were very friendly too. Room was clean and tidy. Not a fancy stay but fine for the price. "

"Beautiful serene property. Lovely stay. "

"Part of staying here is to have your own private jacuzzi. Ours was broken. Didn’t get to enjoy our stay like we had planned to. By time it was fixed, it was already midnight. Service guy was super kind & helpful. Wish staff had sent him earlier in the evening like they said they would. Shower is tiny. Hotel is cute but could use a good touch up. It has a lot of potential to be better. Tiki bar outside was closed. We didn’t get beach passes. Property was not adults only. Morning of check out,...

"Great location and the owner is simply the best! She gave me insights and tips about the area that were useful. Other patrons were nice and courteous. I recommend this hotel and I will be back "

"Bad mAttress and dingy towels and clean pleasant room and facilities and friendly staff."

"Wonderful getaway spot. Clean, modern rooms, grills, tv, fridge, microwave… Beautiful views. Uber or drive 5-10 minutes to restaurants and bars…grocery store. "

"The view of the bay is incredible ( I was on 2nd floor) but the structure itself needs some t l c, fresh paint, more tables in room, etc. "

"Nice motel. Each room is different. Pool is small but clean and the kids had a blast"

"The property looks tired and worn out. The AC in my room was located high on the wall and I had to have someone come in to stand on a desk to turn it on. It was extremely efficient after that was done. The mattresses/beds were extremely comfortable. The rooms were immaculate, although very old. It was very quiet and served my purpose very well. "

"was fine. clean only stayed for 10 hours"

"The area was safe and quiet and it was right off the higway. There were places to eat and shop near by The room smelled of cleaning products and the rooms were dated however we were only spending a night in a budget hotel so you get what you pay for the room had two beds and one had a stain on the sheet so we slept in the other and that one had a stain on the comforter the breakfast was continental so recommend eating someplace else. breakfast was in a brown bag and was a donut and a granola...

"If you’re looking for in inexpensive, no frills, motel, Lamplighter Motel is about as good as you’ll find. "