Search Cottages in Buckeye Lake

"We stayed to celebrate our daughter's graduation from Denison University. This house was too small to host any kind of celebration party but it was perfect for our family to stay. The houses in the neighborhood are close together yet it was very quiet. And it's such an easy drive to Granville. There are so many amenities that it truly was very easy to feel like we were at home. Kelly was so responsive and left such thoughtful treats. I just wish we had had more time to enjoy Buckeye Lake and the...

"This was a great place to stay! The rooms were a little small but still great! I would highly recommend this home to anyone. The owners are extremely responsive and respectful. There is a lot to do close by. I highly recommend crenos pizza, Millersport coffee, and mill dam bar and grille!"

"This is such a cute, clean, well-managed property! Highly recommend for Denison families wanting to spend some time by the lake."

"Family of 4 enjoyed our stay in this adorable home by the lake."

"Inside was cozy yard wasn’t considering the neighbors"

"The house is small and cute. Beds are comfortable. The bedrooms have no closet or dresser but a metal stand with hangers and a couple of shelves. Since we rented for 2 weeks it was hard to manage our stuff. Additional hooks in the bathroom would have helped with hanging towels. The place is dark - could use a light on the desk. It needs some cozy touches like pillows for the couch and maybe a throw. That said, I would rent again as it was very convenient to the workshop place. Owner was...

"This was our second time staying at this property and it was another perfect visit! The house is spacious and is wonderfully cared for. Very clean, nice furniture, plenty of extra towels and blankets. We loved exploring the little trail out back and watching the herons build their nests. We will absolutely be coming back again!"

"The property was absolutely amazing! Sitting on the dock with the lights on and a fire nearby is how we ended every night. Also, the house itself is much bigger than we even thought! The owners even stopped by an restocked our wood pile which was awesome! Overall this is an amazing place to rent out, and is a contender to be a reoccurring annual guys trip location!"

"It was a very spacious beautifully renovated home. Everything you need!"

"Great stay. Wonderful location. Perfect accommodations, very clean."

"Rick was the most gracious host -- he even reached out to us to see when we would be arriving and greeted us! His properties are very clean, very well maintained, and exactly as described."

"The rental has a great view of the cove and is conveniently located for many activities in the area."

"We stayed to celebrate our daughter's graduation from Denison University. This house was too small to host any kind of celebration party but it was perfect for our family to stay. The houses in the neighborhood are close together yet it was very quiet. And it's such an easy drive to Granville. There are so many amenities that it truly was very easy to feel like we were at home. Kelly was so responsive and left such thoughtful treats. I just wish we had had more time to enjoy Buckeye Lake and the...