Top Motels in Central Eleuthera in 2026

A church with a bell tower, green shutters, and a cross on top.

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

Next weekend

In two weeks

In one month

In two months

Our top choices for Central Eleuthera motels

1. Daddy Joes

Gregory Town

Robert

View all properties

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Top Central Eleuthera Hotel Reviews

La Bougainvillea Hotel and Villas

10/10 Excellent

"."

Sky Beach Club

8/10 Good

"I thoroughly enjoyed my stay af the Beach Club, Bungalow 1. Mr. Rolle, manager, and Virginia, staff, were very professional and courteous and ensured all my needs were met. The road to bungalows however could use some renovation works - a rental car however is still fine for transportation back and forth. I highly recommend the Sky Beach Club and would most definitely stay there again."

BEACHFRONT HOME AND POOL, 4BR/4 BATHROOMS

10/10 Excellent

"Amazing view , beach all to ourselves. We didn’t realize Sept 5 was beginning of low season so almost all restaurants closed. Grocery store open. If you want a totally relaxing week , it is perfect. Pool is being renovated next month but was cool and refreshing. Had an awesome day with Cpt bubba and fishbone tours!! Everyone was so nice and kind, house was perfect for our group of 4. Prepared to relax and unplug !!!!We will be back. !!"

High-End Caribbean-front Home in Top location-Pool, Amazing Views & Generator

10/10 Excellent

"What a very unique property. So very cool to be able to snorkel reefs right from your front yard. Water was a little rough the week we stayed, with poor visibility, but we did see a few tropical fish throughout the week. Jumping off the cliffs was also fun! Romell was very kind and accommodating- he graciously helped my husband and son out of a bind when they got stuck. The Jeep Liberty we rented from him was awesome…my son loved it so much he wants to get one for camping. The house was fine for our needs. I will say it is not quite as new as the pictures made it look, especially the kitchen and bedding, but certainly nothing I would leave a bad rating for, as who can complain about paradise. The views, the colors of the water, and the islanders we met are unforgettable. We have visited 6 of the out islands so far, and Eleuthera is now one of our favorites. We did spend much time up in Spanish Wells, as that is where we rented the boat - from research, fishing and snorkeling from Spanish Wells proved to be the best. A bit of a drive and a ferry each day to get there, but also very worth the effort. We hit many of the beaches both north and south of the rental- there are just too many to visit. Deborah was amazing at communicating, and provided so much information about places to visit and where to get essentials. This is a very special rental that I would have no problem recommending to future guests."

Sea Shanty - Ocean view, Private pool, Walk to Beach, Prime Central Location.

10/10 Excellent

"A cozy and comfortable home! We thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Jethro was very responsive, accommodating, and easy to communicate with throughout our visit. The home had everything we needed for a relaxing stay in Eleuthera, and we truly appreciated the hospitality. We would definitely recommend it to others and would happily stay again!"

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Rainbow Bay Vacations

Room 1

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Central Eleuthera motels

1. Daddy Joes

Top Central Eleuthera Hotel Reviews

La Bougainvillea Hotel and Villas

Pineapple Fields Boutique Condo Hotel

Sky Beach Club

BEACHFRONT HOME AND POOL, 4BR/4 BATHROOMS

High-End Caribbean-front Home in Top location-Pool, Amazing Views & Generator

OceanWaves, A Vacation to Remember!A 1minute walk to private gazebo and beach.

Daddy Joes

Sea Shanty - Ocean view, Private pool, Walk to Beach, Prime Central Location.

Trade Winds - Oceanview, Private Pool, Short Walk To Pink Sand Beach, Central.

Explore a world of travel with Expedia