We had a wonderful week with our family (6 adults, a 4-year-old, and a 2-year-old).
The good:
1) The view with lots of places you could just sit and read or talk and enjoy it.
2) The friendliness of the host. Leny met us with a smile when we arrived and showed us around. After that, to be honest, we had little need to contact the host as everything was as expected and worked well.
3) How well stocked it was...everything we could possibly want was provided. We especially appreciated the enormous supply of plush towels.
4) It was spotlessly clean and pretty much everything was in good working order.
5) The layout. With the exception of the master bedroom, the other bedrooms are away from the living space. The main living area made great use of the view and was fun to hang out in (though, of course, we spent most of our time outside).
6) The location. You felt like you were in the woods, but we were close enough to town to make a run for coffee and donuts when you felt like it.
7) Did I mention the view?
The not-quite-so-good:
1) The grill worked but probably needs to be replaced after the season.
2) Figuring out the light switches. Some are in strange spots (kitchen behind the fridge, master bedroom has two switches not wired correctly so you have to make sure to switch both on, etc.)
3) The bathrooms are tiny and dated. We did expect based on the price for them to be more modern, especially as there was no good place for toiletries, etc. in some of them. The kitchen is dated too, though that really did not make much of a difference... functions just fine.
4) If you are a biker, you need to be very careful on the road to the house. Loose gravel and up and down was fine by car but a bit slippery by bike.
5) Not so obvious from the pictures, the house is set quite high up above the lake so there is a several-story staircase. Mostly an issue if you have little kids or fewer mobile adults. In practice, it was not an issue and it contributed to the outstanding view.
The bad:
1) Really nothing...we might very well go back next season.