Search Cottages in Greencastle

"I first want to say I never wanted to leave, Eleuthera is an amazing island and something very special. If you want a secluded house with a private beach to enjoy the views of the ocean, this is the place. The blue water views when you walk in are amazing and the property offers so much! The house is beautiful plenty of room for a family, the kitchen is well equipped with everything you need, best past is an amazing ice maker we used excessively! There are three different types of coffee makers, plenty of pots and pans, spices! The beds are very comfy, and the AC keeps each room cool! It’s great to have the pool right out back, there were even rafts and blow ups for the kids! There are steps down to the private beach we didn’t see anyone the whole trip! It’s very shallow and clear, great for some easy snow, the best part was the numerous sea turtles everywhere!! We saw other sea life, sting rays, crabs, fish, even tiny sharks! Nish was a wonderful perk of the house, she was so attentive and kind, she cleans twice a week and even brought us fresh mangos from her yard!! She helped us with all of our questions and gave us great recommendations on things to do, she is fabulous!! Everyone on the island is so friendly and welcoming, we will be back!! "

"Parlay at Sunset was a great stay. There were a few minor hiccups from the previous renters, but Charles the property manager took care of things within a timely manner. We had a wonderful stay, and the private beach area was serene and blissful. My family had fun shell hunting. I recommend Parlay at Sunset for your Tarpum Bay stay. "

"The property itself was run down and dirty. The location was great."

"The nicest most friendly hosts in a lovely room with all the amenities. So grateful to them. I wholeheartedly recommend you come and enjoy a stay here."

"What an amazing property!! We absolutely loved everything about this area, condo, and host. The sunrise views and beach were simply spectacular and the host was wonderful to work with."

"Family of 6, kids ages 18-26. House and beach were incredible. Best beach in the world! Host extremely responsive to all requests. Access to club house and pickleball and Gym a big plus. 100% would stay again!!"

"The property is set off the main highway making it easy to find but there is very little traffic so highway noise is not a problem. The beach is a great walking and swimming beach. The water is relatively shallow allowing one to walk out 50 yards or so and being only waist deep. It would be perfect for those who like to just swim or sit in the cool water. It would also make a great place for beginning snorkelers. There is a "chickee" at the waters edge to sit or lie in the rope hammock and look out at the peaceful ocean. Additional furniture would there would be nice. The house is very comfortable and well laid out with an open design of the kitchen and living area. The double screened doors allow the ocean breeze through the house. The house has a sitting porch in the front and back so you can always stay out of the sun! There is an outdoor shower for rinsing off after being in the ocean. Eleuthera is a very rural island so dont expect there to be lots to see or do except visit different beaches. There are no casinos, resorts, etc.in this area. However, if you are looking for secluded beaches and friendly people then you will like this place. There is a relatively decent market (island wise) about 2 kilometers away in Tarpum Bay and a bigger one in Rock Sound (a 20 minute drive). We have rented close to 50 VRBO homes all over the world (we love traveling!) and the host, Barbara Carey, was the best and the quickest to respond to any questions we had by far"

"The cottage was perfect for my husband, myself and my parents. It’s well appointed and a close drive from Rock sound airport. Easy access to the grocery store. Thank you! Athalyn"

"Wonderful house and location. Loved every minute of our stay ."