
Find all hotels by Independent in Hay Island
- Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
- Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Top Hay Island Hotel Reviews

Shenstone Motor Inn & Restaurant
10/10 Excellent
Explore a world of travel with Expedia
Explore more hotels
- 7-Bedroom Family Retreat • Golf Simulator • Hot Tub • Game Room • Near Tobermory
- Gorgeous Waterfront Cottage with Sauna + Canoe
- Cozy/private cabin located in Lions head beside Bruce trail!
- Blue Moon Cottage
- Waterfront Adults Only Private Cabin Sleep 4
- Play, dine and relax amongst the beauty of Georgian Bay and The Bruce Trail.
- Dreamers Writing Farm
- Spacious modern cottage with incredible views in the Bruce Peninsula
- Contemporary Million Dollar View Getaway
- The Kutir - Entire Cottage - 6 Privacy Acres in Meaford - 5 Mins to Georgian Bay
- "Paradise" 66 Acres of Private Trails & 200' Waterfront
- Luxury oasis in the woods, less than five minutes from the beach!
- Lake View Family Hideaway 1 Bedroom, sleep 2
- LAKEHOUSE CHALET on Sky Lake, 5 Bed, Majestic Sunsets and Spacious living
- Peninsula Perch: Water & Trails
- Waterfront Villa on Bruce Peninsula | Hot Tub, Fire Pits, Kayaks & Sleeps 12
- Purgatory Cove - Private Waterfront Escape
- Waterfront Green Cottage Pike Bay
- Welcome to the Lake House
- White Cloud and Griffith







