15 Best Cabins in Monticello, IN - Cabins for Rent from AED 1,093

Best Western Plus Brandywine Inn & Suites

8/10 Good

"Breakfast was nothing to write home about. There were no meat options. The biscuits were hard and dry. Eggs were decent."

Alexanders Landing

8/10 Good

"They thought of every detail, unfortunately with the exception of the furniture. We found the beds and the sofa to be very uncomfortable-this place would be an absolute 5star review with more comfortable furnishings. Overall we enjoyed our stay and the location was perfect for us."

Charming Cottage on Lake Shafer-optional Pontoon! Screened gazebo and swim deck!

10/10 Excellent

"The house was beautifully decorated and extremely clean. Everything you could possibly need was there, including toiletries in case you forgot something and life jackets, awesome water mats and pool noodles for the lake. The large deck with the dining table and fire-table was where we spent our evenings eating and enjoying each other's company. Kelly was wonderful to work with and always available. The house is close to everything you need, yet feels far away and peaceful. We had a great time and would definitely consider renting again in the future."

Home on Lake Shafer with 120 Ft Waterfront

8/10 Good

"The inside of the property was great for our group of 6. Grandsons had fun playing and swimming in channel. Only thing was there was alot of poison ivy in back on stairs so made sure kids stayed away. Nothing major."

Blue Door Cottages

10/10 Excellent

"Very easy to communicate with host. Rules were well laid out. We will stay again."

The Lake House Everyone Wants w/two decks, great amenities & optional Pontoon!

10/10 Excellent

"Absolutely AMAZING! This was hands down one of the best vacation rentals we’ve ever stayed in! We had 6 adults, 1 toddler, and 2 dogs, and there was more than enough room for everyone to relax and enjoy the beautiful lake.The owners have truly thought of EVERYTHING. We were blown away by all of the thoughtful extras throughout the house—from makeup remover wipes, sugar, flour, paper plates, batteries, and sunscreen to countless other little conveniences that made us feel completely at home. You can tell they genuinely care about their guests’ experience.The pontoon boat was the highlight of our trip! We spent hours cruising around the lake, making unforgettable memories together. A huge shoutout to Jason, who took the time to show us how to operate the pontoon. He was so friendly, patient, down-to-earth, and accommodating, making us feel comfortable and confident before heading out on the water.This home made our Fourth of July weekend absolutely perfect. From the incredible amenities to the beautiful lake and outstanding hospitality, every detail exceeded our expectations. We made memories that will last a lifetime and can’t wait to come back. If you’re considering booking this lake house, don’t hesitate—you won’t be disappointed!Thank you again Kelly and Kevin !!"

Monticello Inn

10/10 Excellent

"The room was clean and the staff was very friendly. They answered any questions I had. The property was conveniently located just outside of town. It was about a 10 minute drive to Indiana Beach."

Lake Freeman house w/boat dock... Minutes from Indiana Beach/Lake Shafer

10/10 Excellent

"If you have the chance to stay at this property, DO IT! We have stayed in many rentals in the area, but this location was so beautiful. Every single day of our stay, we saw wildlife of some kind: snails, doe and her fawn, and herons. The view from the balcony was gorgeous! It was a very relaxing property on the water. We did plenty of fishing and boating. A deer walked right up to us while fishing one evening. With young children, it can be hard to find a suitable rental. I appreciate the minimal “knickknacks” around the house. (I didn’t have to childproof much!) The hosts also put up many safety reminders, and that was reassuring. Even with a high balcony, I didn’t feel that I had to hover over them. We had exactly what we needed! The hosts provided many extra pillows and blankets, plenty of cutlery, and various board games. There was lots of room for our whole family, dog included! The hosts also left a thorough welcome binder that detailed rules and other policies, plus local recommendations. We hope to come back soon!"

Lake-Level Retreat w Hot Tub, Picture Windows & 65” TV for Ultimate Relaxation

10/10 Excellent

"Great property! Super clean and cozy with lots to do if you want to just stay on site!"

Room 1

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Monticello cabin rentals

Escape to The Riverside Hideaway - A Cozy Cabin With River Views!

Rustic Cabin Near Purdue University

Rustic Cabin-Farmhouse Vibe Secluded with Hot Tub

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Top Monticello Hotel Reviews

Best Western Plus Brandywine Inn & Suites

Alexanders Landing

Charming Cottage on Lake Shafer-optional Pontoon! Screened gazebo and swim deck!

Home on Lake Shafer with 120 Ft Waterfront

Blue Door Cottages

The Lake House Everyone Wants w/two decks, great amenities & optional Pontoon!

Monticello Inn

Lake Freeman house w/boat dock... Minutes from Indiana Beach/Lake Shafer

Lake-Level Retreat w Hot Tub, Picture Windows & 65” TV for Ultimate Relaxation

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Top Cabin Rentals in Other Destinations

More Accommodation Types in Monticello

Search Cabin Rentals in Monticello

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Monticello cabin rentals

Escape to The Riverside Hideaway - A Cozy Cabin With River Views!

Rustic Cabin Near Purdue University

Rustic Cabin-Farmhouse Vibe Secluded with Hot Tub

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Top Monticello Hotel Reviews

Best Western Plus Brandywine Inn & Suites

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Top Cabin Rentals in Other Destinations

More Accommodation Types in Monticello