15 Best Cabins in Otter Lake, NY - Cabins for Rent from AED 1,217

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks

In two months

In three months

In four months

Our top choices for Otter Lake cabin rentals

A kitchen with wooden cabinets, a central island with stools, a refrigerator, and a microwave.

1. Brantingham Lake cabin with waterfront access

Greig

Vicki H.

AED 1,283 total

includes taxes & fees

14 Nov - 15 Nov

A modern A-frame cabin with a deck, surrounded by a forest.

2. New Luxury A-Frame Cabin, 10 Min from Old Forge with Hot tub and Privacy

Forestport

AED 1,813 total

includes taxes & fees

15 Nov - 16 Nov

A cabin surrounded by snow-covered trees.

3. Cabin close to town, private beach, parking & hot tub

Old Forge

Erika B.

AED 1,477 total

includes taxes & fees

29 Nov - 30 Nov

A small wooden cabin with a porch, two windows, and a door.

4. Cozy Adirondack Cabin - Snowmobile & Pet Friendly

Cold Brook

BENJAMIN

AED 1,217 total

includes taxes & fees

15 Nov - 16 Nov

A two-story log cabin with a stone foundation, a porch with red chairs, and a stone retaining wall.

5. 1st Lake Cabin, Beach/Waterfront, Hot Tub & Sauna

Old Forge

AED 2,254 total

includes taxes & fees

16 Nov - 17 Nov

A cabin with a fire pit, outdoor seating, and a covered porch.

6. Private Multi-family Adirondack lakefront cabin with 4 bedrooms 2 full baths

Greig

"Having the two apartments side by side with a connecting door was perfect for our situation. Both parties had privacy when needed but could easily share cooking,food and time together as they wished. So many amenities were provided like soaps, paper towels, tissues, garbage bags, linens and even wood for the fire pit. The host was amazing to work with. We loved that we were not butted right up against other lake houses but had space which gave our dog some freedom. The dog loved the water. The...

Janice S.

AED 2,279 total

includes taxes & fees

16 Nov - 17 Nov

View all properties

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Apartments

Private vacation homes

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Sign in

Sign up, it's free

Top Otter Lake Hotel Reviews

Matteson’s Rental Cabins

10/10 Excellent

"Cozy & clean, with comfortable beds. There was a beautiful, high pine ceiling, in addition to the walls. The bathroom was fine, too. The store nearby was very helpful with various grocery items, beautiful Christmas wreaths as well. Hosts were friendly & helpful. I plan on staying again. A"

ADIRONDACK LUXURY LAKE ESTATE: LAKE & POOL & HOT TUB! NEWLY RENOVATED!

10/10 Excellent

"We had such a wonderful time here on our annual family weekend getaway. The property is beautiful and has amazing views. The house is spacious, open, inviting and very comfortable. Also impeccably clean. Very family friendly with plenty to do to keep everyone entertained."

Waterfront Camp with Boathouse - Wifi, kayaks, canoe and sandy bottom out front.

8/10 Good

"We enjoyed our stay at Ferienhaus. The location and views were perfect- night sky from the top of the boathouse was unbelievable. We spent a lot time in the living room with a cozy fire playing board games. The host was very prompt responding to messages. We did have issues figuring out the heat- temps were in the 30s our first night and although the front of the house was quite comfortable, the back two bedrooms were easily 10-15 degrees cooler and we couldn’t figure out how to get it warmer back there. We would also strongly suggest new mattresses- they have toppers but the king visibly dips in the middle. My husband ended up sleeping in the living room due to the temp and mattress issues."

Spacious Adirondack House in Otter Lake

10/10 Excellent

"The house in Otter lake was wonderful! Located a short 10 minute drive from Old Forge it provides a very comfortable and enjoyable place to stay for multiple nights. Plenty of space for our group of five people the interior is pleasantly decorated with unique artwork and a rustic cabin like feel. We especially enjoyed the heated floor in the kitchen and the upstairs view from the window of the winding road, it looked like a painting. The owner is great to deal with and gave us a free homemade loaf of bread, which was delicious! We would recommend this home to anyone and would be happy to stay there again."

HTR Adirondacks

8/10 Good

"The location ON the Moose River was gorgeous but the cottages are VERY close so it was a little noisy. The decorations on the grounds for Halloween were adorable! It was difficult to learn how to operate the TV and the heaters (it was cold in the mornings). There were no instructions left to run either item and when we called the number listed, we could only leave a message but nobody called us back. We had to wait till the next day when the office was open ..then someone came right away. The shower was NOT spotless, and the floors weren't super clean. The main bedroom was ok but the bunks in the bunk room were small and not so clean under the mattresses. There was only ONE small area to hang clothes. They left no cleaning supplies or paper towels to clean before we left."

Room 1

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Otter Lake cabin rentals

1. Brantingham Lake cabin with waterfront access

2. New Luxury A-Frame Cabin, 10 Min from Old Forge with Hot tub and Privacy

3. Cabin close to town, private beach, parking & hot tub

4. Cozy Adirondack Cabin - Snowmobile & Pet Friendly

5. 1st Lake Cabin, Beach/Waterfront, Hot Tub & Sauna

6. Private Multi-family Adirondack lakefront cabin with 4 bedrooms 2 full baths

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Top Otter Lake Hotel Reviews

Matteson’s Rental Cabins

ADIRONDACK LUXURY LAKE ESTATE: LAKE & POOL & HOT TUB! NEWLY RENOVATED!

Adirondack 503

The Guide’s River Cottage • Riverfront Retreat + Walk to Town

Waterfront Camp with Boathouse - Wifi, kayaks, canoe and sandy bottom out front.

Adirondack Waterfront Lodge Close to Old Forge with A/C and Heated Garage

Spacious Adirondack House in Otter Lake

12 Mi to Old Forge Pond! Group Basecamp w/ Grill

HTR Adirondacks

Search Cabin Rentals in Otter Lake

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Otter Lake cabin rentals

1. Brantingham Lake cabin with waterfront access

2. New Luxury A-Frame Cabin, 10 Min from Old Forge with Hot tub and Privacy

3. Cabin close to town, private beach, parking & hot tub

4. Cozy Adirondack Cabin - Snowmobile & Pet Friendly

5. 1st Lake Cabin, Beach/Waterfront, Hot Tub & Sauna

6. Private Multi-family Adirondack lakefront cabin with 4 bedrooms 2 full baths

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Top Otter Lake Hotel Reviews

Matteson’s Rental Cabins