This is one of the finest rentals we have used thru VRBO and is perfectly suited for a couple's retreat. Pros are that the layout is very efficient, clean, new appliances and fixtures, the most comfortable bed of any rental we have ever encountered, very comfortable sheets and blankets, excellent location relative to all that Sedona has to offer, and very responsive owners.
The cons are the odd request to not flush toilet paper in the toilet - I'm familiar with septic tank systems and this is not at all a standard feature of the systems...but, I am not the owner and respect their request. If you can get around this aspect, it's a minor issue and easy to get used to. Our cell carrier is Verizon and our service in the area of the rental was terrible (this of course has nothing to do with the owner). Not sure if this is common, but the WiFi provided by the owner was extremely slow during our 4 day/3 night stay - like less than 2 mbps slow - so, it was basically unusable. Finally, although there are two TVs, neither one features local news stations or a typical cable package. We experienced inclement weather, so it would've been nice to have been able to consult with local news weather outlooks.
None of the cons mentioned above are bad enough to lower the 5-star score - this casita is that nice and reasonably priced.