Find all hotels by Independent in Shelter Island, NY from AED 320

"Loved the peacefulness and the view from the deck!! Great place!! Would absolutely return!! Sherry Hill"

"loved it "

"Our stay at the Montauk Blue was great, The well definitely be back in the future. "

"We were greeted so beautifully by Cassandra and the young man she was training at the guest registration. She is a gem! Loved sitting out on the patio and admiring the magnificence of the water and the grounds. The buildings were immaculate 24/7 and our room was pristine! We will definitely be returning! Thank you!"

"The quiet, the cleanliness, the comfort, and staff friendliness."

"People are amazing! Super kind and caring!! "

"Manager was awful. Her name was Janice nessel . We had no water for showers and we were told by her that once one person takes a shower it takes 20 minutes for the tank to get warm. She said we don’t tell our guests that. That is disgraceful. She was rude also and offered no compensation. Ironic thing was the showers were great once we knew we had to wait in between. Property was amazing except for her. She should not be allowed to deal with people. So rude. . I should have read reviews before I went as there was so many complaints against her it was unbelievable. Property was great. "

"Amazing location. Everything is new and fresh. Lovely small, well-heated pool. Room is minimalist chic. No TV set. Staff is friendly and helpful. Restaurant was not open as it was a Monday to Tuesday stay. 8AM yoga class was great. Complimentary continental breakfast was also nice. All of the public spaces are chic and comfortable."

"Amazing!!"