Find all hotels by Benchmark in Upper Matecumbe Key, FL

"Property was truly beautiful with friendly staff and amazing amenities. The free shuttle to the other resorts was a great surprise as well. We took the Rum Runner for breakfast (shout out to Captain Dave and Bruce for being amazing). In my opinion, Amara Cay was the nicest of the three resorts if you’re looking for island luxury and a truly relaxing experience. Will definitely be visiting again!"

"Clean, beautiful, family friendly resort. Staff was friendly and accommodating. Will definitely be back!"

"Outstanding "

"Walls are a bit thin but not bad. This resort is family friendly. "

"Everything was great. We enjoyed the complimentary water activities and access to sister resorts. "

"This is a secret gem, highly recommend. Great location, rooms are nice and the beach and pool are great! The attached restaurant snooks is delicious. "

"Very nice room with walk out directly to water, amazing sunsets, cant wait to come back."

"Great stay! The hotel was very clean, comfortable, and well-maintained. The staff was friendly and always ready to help, which made the experience even better. Everything was exactly as expected. I would definitely stay here again. Highly recommend!"

"Breakfast was amazing at the restaurant! This resort is fabulous and it truly feels like you are on a tropical private island! We will definitely be back! "