Find all hotels by Extended Stay America in City Island, NY

"Room was clean with nice amenities, and it was quiet at night. The breakfast was great, and staff were friendly. "

"Great"

"It’s a good price and seemed safe."

"Es un gran sitio"

"nice hotel. great time"

"We were disappointed that we had no refrigerator in the room. My husband is a diabetic and has meds to be refrigerated. Went down to ask to have one brought up. Manager that was on got us an upgraded room. We were down to one elevator and long lines but this was not the staff issue. Enjoyed our stay !!!!"

"Really enjoyed our stay. Room was spacious and clean. Staff was very attentive. Was within walking distance of everything! Going to make this our go to in NYC!"

"The Sheraton was very nice and I wouldn’t discourage anyone from staying here. The location was great for what I wanted to do while visiting. There were some areas for improvement. Our room didn’t have a TV remote. I had to request one. The water pressure in the shower was solid, but I would have liked more. Lastly, the AC in the room didn’t seem to make the room as cold as I wanted."

"Good location. Overall good facilities condition. Place is clean and staff is really friendly."