Find all hotels by Independent in Carlisle Bay

"The resort was great. Good food, great beach, nice entertainment. I would return."

"I wish that there were activities to do solo. Kayak or something. I’m a solo traveler. Lovely area. Very well maintained. Food was excellent. Staff was fantastic. Everything easy to find and manageable. Very quick to service needs. I came in from a horrible resort to here due to lack of water, electricity. They got me into an area to shower and a drink in hand asap. Really turned my vacation and vibe around. Great pool bar, beautiful beaches and area. 4.7 stars. The behavior from a minority of the black bracelets (you wear red or black, black has a butler) was appalling. They must have never travelled or seen anything anywhere before, VERY obnoxious behavior. "

"Where should I start this horrid revelation of a review at? The loss of power, wifi, water and no food. Traveling as a solo female and have travelled many times solo prior. This place is comparable to the Shawshank Redemption of motels. This IS NOT A RESORT. This place is owned by the government and they do not maintain this hell hole. The only thing pleasant there was the staff and the view and that DOES NOT INCLUDE THE FRONT DESK STAFF. No communication. Management just laughed at the issue that had been going on for days. I arrived to this. Just “you’re holding the line from others checking in” to multiple people requesting information about the whereabouts of water, food and electricity. Had to sleep with the doors open to get air. Was ate completely up by mosquitoes. Horrible beds, might as well slept on the floor. Disgusting bathrooms. There was no water to even drink. Walked to the beach to clear my head, was came at by everyone on the island selling this that or the other. That is not a protected resort. I had to walk to a bodega to charge my phone in order to call Expedia to get tf out of this hell hole. DO NOT STAY HERE. Please!! If you want to Enjoy any portion of your vacation, I beg of you, DO NOT STAY HERE. You would be better sleeping with the animals on the beach. "

"Generally good"

"Amazing staff and amazing rooms, lovely place to stay for a relaxing holiday. Would definitely recommend and stay again. "

"Hotel was awesome!! Clean rooms. The bartenders awesome as well!! Q and andre the dynamic duo!! Restaurant was ok , could be better. The lobster was great though!!! Would go back. "

"The Staff was lovely and accommodating. The property was quiet. Prickly Pear Island is a huge amenity. "

"Good all round"

"I loved this place! Location was fantastic. Short walk to a pretty beach and loads of great restaurants. Check out Indian summer - on the water, great Indian food and cocktails, that’s life - on the water amazing crispy duck and cocktails, and Me and You- adorable place on the water for coffee. Seabreeze is wonderful for coffee and breakfast wraps. My large balcony had a beautiful view of the harbor. The room was large and clean with a great little kitchen. Music from bars was loud but just one night and not for too long. Staff were lovely. Taxi and car rental nearby."