Find all hotels by Independent in Fair Haven, NY from AED 275

"This was a great choice, I like that it is away from the main city area, it was very quiet here. My room (5) was perfect! Super clean, comfy bed, fantastic lighting, good water pressure, really nice towels, and the full size fridge was a nice plus. It was great to be able to refreeze my travel ice packs. The self closing screen door, roll of paper towels, and the note pad were a nice bonus."

"Quiet setting and friendly host"

"Friendly, efficient staff and excellent hotel room. "

"Our family had an absolutely wonderful stay at this home on Sodus Bay. The location couldn’t be more perfect—the private beach was ideal for relaxing mornings with coffee, and the dock made it so easy to get out on the water. We spent hours swimming, kayaking, and just taking in the views.The house itself was spotless, spacious, and well-stocked with everything we needed. The layout worked great for our family—the in-law unit gave us extra space and privacy, which was a huge plus. The main home was bright and welcoming, with plenty of room for everyone to spread out while still feeling cozy and connected.What really stood out was how thoughtful everything was. From the comfortable beds to the well-equipped kitchen, it’s clear that a lot of care goes into making guests feel at home. We especially loved evenings by the fire! It was the perfect way to end each day.This place made our family trip truly special, and we’re already talking about coming back. Highly recommend it to anyone looking for a peaceful, fun, and memorable getaway on the bay!"

"Manager very friendly and welcoming! Room was dated but very clean and newly decorated! All amenities were good! Will definitely be back next year!"

"Seamless check-in, lots of room for the family to spread out or all sit together at the same table. Pool is well cared for and there is plenty of shade and sun on the deck. Beds are comfortable, place was clean, 2 frig's! So nice to have bay access with a dock, fish we're caught! 5 minute drive to a wonderful winery or lake Ontario Stone beach in the other direction."

"Great bed"

"Beautiful location for a relaxing family vacation!"

"Beds are super comfortable and clean! Free wifi! As I say Everytime I love this place!! The owner is always super nice and generous! Thank you! "