Top Cottages in Herkimer County in 2026

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Top cities in Herkimer County

A lake surrounded by dense forest, a small town with buildings, and a bridge connecting the town to the mainland.

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Check prices for these dates

Next weekend

In two weeks

In one month

In two months

Our top choices for Herkimer County cottages

A rustic building with a prominent tower, large windows, and a covered porch area.

1. 6418 Cottage: Charming 2BR Farm Stay Minutes from Dreams Park

Fly Creek

Daanish A.

A wooden deck overlooking a pond with a grassy area and trees in the background.

2. Cooperstown Dreams Park, All Star Village & Hall of Fame cottage rental.

Milford

Big M.

A small, single-story house with a porch, a front door, and a window.

3. Charming Village Cottage

Hartwick

Joy H.

A white single-story house with a front porch, a green door, and a wreath.

4. Quaint Village Cottage

Hartwick

Gina G.

5. Delightful Pinecone cottage in the charming village of Inlet

Inlet

"The house itself is nice. WiFi did not work, which rendered the TVs also useless.The water pressure is lowHot water in the shower did not workHost had no problem responding to emails about booking but then ghosted us when I asked about the WiFi. I didnt bother mentioning the hot water situation. Why not? I guess I didn’t feel like typing emails to myself any longer.There was also a bunch of food items in the fridge and pantries. We left them there as they weren’t ours to throw out or...

John A.

A cozy, sunlit room with a round table, two orange chairs, a rocking chair, and a small desk with a sign.

6. StarField Cottage...The Perfect Cooperstown Dreams Park Getaway!

Cooperstown

pat f.

A green cottage with a porch and steps, surrounded by trees.

7. Eagle Bay Cottage with Lake Rights

Eagle Bay

John H.

A two-story red building with a balcony, surrounded by trees and a grassy yard.

8. Feather & Fern @ Cooperstown Lodge 3 to CDP + Pool

Cooperstown

Dustin G.

A small cabin with a patio, surrounded by a grassy yard and dense forest.

9. 1 Mi to Brantingham Lake: New York Getaway!

Brantingham

Kim K.

A wooden deck with a railing overlooking a grassy field and a house with a red roof.

10. Country Escape w/ Sauna, 10 Mi to Cooperstown

Richfield Springs

View all properties

Top reviews in Herkimer County

A wooden porch with a view of a road and distant trees during sunset.

The Meadowlark Inn

Cherry Valley

10/10 Excellent

Chuck

A wooden building with a covered entrance, a stone pathway leading to it, and a landscaped garden with mulch and small plants.

Ashling Acres

Hamilton

10/10 Excellent

Anthony

A sign for Grand Colonial Bed and Breakfast with a brick building in the background.

Grand Colonial B&B

Herkimer

10/10 Excellent

James

A large, historic house with multiple towers and a prominent chimney.

Haslett House

Fort Plain

10/10 Excellent

Spectacular interior spaces and super friendly owner. The interior is filled with incredible woodwork, especially grand staircase. Our suite was large and comfortable. Books everywhere to read. Great amount of satisfying choices for breakfast. We were pleasantly stuffed afterwards. Close to several restaurants. We were biking the Erie Canal Trail from Syracuse to Amsterdam NY and it was very convenient, close to trail and owner insisted on having our bikes inside. Loved it!!!

Roger

A covered outdoor seating area with a view of a lake and trees.

Great Pines

Old Forge

10/10 Excellent

jodie

A stone building with a Coca-Cola vending machine, a chair outside, and an American flag.

Clark's Beach Motel

Old Forge

10/10 Excellent

allyson

The Inn at Cooperstown

Cooperstown

10/10 Excellent

Michael

An outdoor patio with a stone wall, a blue sofa, orange chairs, and a glass-top table.

Hampton Inn Cooperstown

Cooperstown

10/10 Excellent

Our family stayed in multiple rooms for 2 nights in April during spring break so we could visit the National Baseball Hall of Fame. The hotel was one week new and in a great location. The staff was friendly, helpful and on point. They really did a great job with the guests. The pool is an average size, nice, heated, and there is an outdoor space as well. For anyone who walks daily, there is a nice space around the hotel along the creek. They have a daily continental breakfast that worked out...

Keri

A two-story white building with green shutters, a red door, and a flag on the front porch.

The White House Inn

Cooperstown

10/10 Excellent

Wendy

A two-story house with a front porch, a small garden, and two Adirondack chairs.

Landmark Inn

Cooperstown

10/10 Excellent

James

A two-story house with a large garage, a covered porch, and a wooden staircase leading to the upper floor.

The Balsam Inn

Caroga Lake

10/10 Excellent

It was a real treat to stay at the Balsam Inn! The Inn is off the beaten path like I wanted and very very quite. Jenny is a warm welcoming host. She even upgraded my room just because it was available. The room itself was beautiful! It felt like I was a guest in someones Adirondack mountain home. Antique furniture, pines cones, snowshoes, layered bedding...like in an LLBean catalog. The bed was super comfy. I had a large screen TV and mini fridge in the room. Although there is a...

Kathleen