Top Inns in Long Island in 2026

Check prices for these dates

Next weekend

In two weeks

In one month

In two months

Our top choices for Long Island inns

A clear turquoise sea with a sandy beach and rocky outcrops.

1. Two Turtles Inn

George Town

"Two Turtles was the best location. Center of town and walking distance to everything, including the water taxi! Room was just okay. It's more of an Inn or Hostel. No maid service during your stay, so you have to ask for new towels, etc. Our air conditioning was broken, which would have been fine, but our window did not have screens, so we couldn't open those either. Great people that work there and love the bar! But definitely a 2 star as far as room quality."

Anonymous traveler

A view of a tropical beach with palm trees and a clear blue ocean.

2. Winter Haven

Clarence Town

Anonymous traveler

View all properties

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Sign in

Sign up, it's free

Top Long Island Hotel Reviews

HGTV-Featured Beachfront Villa / Steps to Sand / Resort Amenities Included

10/10 Excellent

"Michael and Roseann were absolutely incredible to work with! I travel fairly often and the customer service I received was something I’ve never experienced. Every little thing we could have possibly needed was there for us. Each time I had a question it was answered within minutes. They went way out of their way to ensure our stay was amazing! We are already hoping to return!!! "

OCEAN FRONT HOME WITH POOL,DOCK-STEPS TO MORIAH NATIONAL PARK

10/10 Excellent

"-We were very impressed with the communication with the host and the property manager. Questions were answered almost immediately and we appreciated all the instructions and information they provided about the island and the departure process at the airport.-The home, like so many places on the island, is way beyond the first impression from the outside. It is extremely well decorated and appointed with all the best appliances and furnishings. And the views from the all-glass back are stunning. We were traveling with another couple and found the living space to be very comfortable and quiet.-We had a great time and are anxious to return!"

Pool, Beach, kayaks, great snorkeling, calm side of the island,

10/10 Excellent

"Jack was super! The house was well stocked. He responded quickly to any issues. The mattresses were so comfortable and this is so important to us! The location is great, a perfect home base for exploring and returning to a gorgeous sunset and relaxing pool. The views are incredible. Highly recommend Jack and his properties!"

Beachwood Villa, Oceanfront near sand flats! Most 5-stars on the island!

10/10 Excellent

"We had a great time and the view was gorgeous! We had 11 ladies and never felt cramped at all. This house was very spacious. There were a few minor wear and tear broken things in the house that I reported, and I feel confident they will repair these things. We loved the pool & pool view, and the small beach was beautiful, Getting down to the beach at the last step of the steps leading to the beach, could be a little hard for those with bad knees. We were able to comfortably float in the ocean 4 days of our stay. It was calm most days, like a pool, but a little rougher 2 of our days! This house is close to Pretty Molly Bay and the Tropic of Cancer beach which were also beautiful:) I will say we did not take the Kayaks out. We did not have men with us, so trying to get them down to the beach, and then back up to the house, would have been a heavy, awkward job for us to conquer! We hope to visit again one day to this place of paradise!"

Amazing Beachfront home the calm side of the island. Swimming & kayaking

10/10 Excellent

"Wow! What a beautiful place!! We loved every moment. Easy check in and great communication In fact, they go above and beyond for you!! Jack and Kay were amazing. There isn’t anything negative we have to say!! Shipwreck had everything we needed. Coffee k-cups, filtered water, air conditioning, and all the kitchen utensils to kayaks!! Jack and Kay communicated very well and were responsive (within minutes). Kay, thank you so very much . You went above and beyond. We will be back and we will let others know about your place!! Until next time."

Room 1

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Long Island inns

1. Two Turtles Inn

2. Winter Haven

Top Long Island Hotel Reviews

HGTV-Featured Beachfront Villa / Steps to Sand / Resort Amenities Included

OCEAN FRONT HOME WITH POOL,DOCK-STEPS TO MORIAH NATIONAL PARK

Pool, Beach, kayaks, great snorkeling, calm side of the island,

Hideaways Exuma

Harbor Breeze Villas

Peace and Plenty Resort

Beachwood Villa, Oceanfront near sand flats! Most 5-stars on the island!

Amazing Beachfront home the calm side of the island. Swimming & kayaking

Stella Marina 4BR Exuma Beachfront Villa with Heated Pool & Ocean Views.

Explore a world of travel with Expedia