Top Vacation Homes in Long Island in 2026

A coastal landscape with a clear blue sea, a sandy beach, and a small island with buildings.

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks

In two months

In three months

In four months

Top Cities in Long Island

A coastal landscape with a road leading to a beach, a large cloud in the sky, and a clear blue ocean.

Our top choices for Long Island vacation homes

On the beach, sun loungers, beach towels

1. Sugar Beach Villa - Private Estate w/ 1000ft Oceanfront, Pool/Hot Tub, Concierge

Williamstown,

Lynn H.

2. Beach House!!! Best location-TAR BAY! Wraparound porch + hammocks!!!

George Town

scott m.

3. Always Calm Beach. No Estate like this in Exuma! Brand New on protected sand bar

Little Exuma, Exuma

charles c.

4. Ocean Front Property With Pool. - George Town

Exuma

Daniel D.

5. NEMO HOUSE-Luxury Beachfront on perfect Beach-Perfect for 4 couples / 2 families

Tar Bay

Robert S.

AED 7,386 total

includes taxes & fees

4 Aug - 5 Aug

6. Paradise! Private Beachfront Home w/ Pool & Beach WiFi!

George Town

Noelle C.

7. Private and quaint 2 bedroom waterfront cottage - 10 minutes from Georgetown

Georgetown, Bahamas

"We had an absolutely amazing stay at this beautiful waterfront cottage. The property is peaceful, private, and exactly as described—perfect for a relaxing getaway. The views are stunning, and being so close to Georgetown made everything super convenient.Everything was clean, comfortable, and well-maintained, and the home had everything we needed. A special thanks to the property manager, Lott, who was incredibly helpful, responsive, and made sure our stay was seamless from start to finish.Highly...

David P.

8. Overwater Bungalow at Georgetown

Exuma

Raquel R.

9. Panoramic ocean view luxury villa with pool, few minutes walk to Palm Bay Beach

Georgetown

Armand L.

10. Beachside Exuma Villa newly remodeled!Great location near resorts & restaurants

Georgetown

Marc C.

11. Bay View vacation Rentals Villa # 1

Rolle town

Marie-Christine G.

12. Seaside Cottage Seabiscuit – Bonefish Flats w/Ocean Views, Family-Friendly!

George Town

Melannie K.

13. Lady Blue Sits On Beautiful Tar Bay Beach-Features Infinity pool/Outdoor Living

George Town

Valerie G.

14. BEACHFRONT! Best Location on Private Lazy River Sand Bar. Always Calm Water!

Moore Hill

"OMG, this home and property were amazing! We loved the remote location and privacy. There were 11 of us traveling together, we loved the privacy of the cabanas and the great gathering spaces both inside and outside of the main home. The beach access was everything we could have hoped for. The island itself was beautiful and the colors of the ocean were indescribable! Everyone we met was kind and welcoming and made you feel right at home. Judy, the Property Manager, is such a great asset…she gave...

Loni J.

15. Ultimate Outdoor Living, In the Heart of Exuma, High above it all

George Town

Melissa P.

16. Stunning ocean views, first-class accommodation - with Pool, Deck & Solar

Georgetown

Darla F.

17. OCEANFRONT, with spectacular infinity pool on Tar Bay. An Exuma paradise.

Exuma

Allen F.

18. 11 steps to the Ocean

George Town

Mary Ellen W.

19. Oceanfront mansion, heated infinity pool. 6 double rooms, 11 beds can sleep 18

George Town

Shawna M.

20. Elegant 3-Bedroom Villa with Gazebo, Deck & Breathtaking Elizabeth Harbor Views!

George Town

"Amazing location fished and snorkled off the dock every day! fish, rays turtles and sharks all swiming past as sit looking out over the beautiful sea! Restaurants and groceries a short walk (but easier with a car). House had everything we needed and so much space. Would 100% recommend to anyone wanting to experience a bit of paradise! Sunday hog roast at chill on stockings island is a must (short water taxi if you dont have a boat) Beach, pool and tennis were great additions to the most fun we...

Rhys L.

View all properties

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Villas

Apartments

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Top Long Island Hotel Reviews

Peace and Plenty Resort

10/10 Excellent

"The private beach"

Great Location, beautiful home on the water,beach, pool and top amenities

10/10 Excellent

"The property and home were exactly as pictured and described. There was so much to do at the house with the pool, dock, kayaks and paddle boards, huge screened in porch, and beachfront for our family with 2 teenagers. Communication prior to our trip, as well as while we were there, was very attentive and helpful regarding the home, activities and restaurants on the island, making sure we’re were happy with our stay. They were even able to have the house stocked with all of our groceries and drinks the day of our arrival.If we are able to come back to vacation in beautiful Exuma (which I hope we do) we would absolutely stay at Jack’s Island House again!"

Saint Francis Resort

10/10 Excellent

"This was the best experience I had at The Bahamas. From touching down at the airport, to check in, to check out. Everything was so well planned on behalf of the resort. I’m so amazed. It was so relaxing and I wish I could stay here forever. Thank you everyone here. I can’t wait to come back again!!"

A Slice Of Tropical Paradise

10/10 Excellent

"This truly is a slice of paradise! This was our first trip to Exuma to celebrate our 25th anniversary. This home is perfectly placed, stocked and cleaned!When I first booked, I reached out to the host to add a day, no issue! Then halfway through our stay, my husband and I found a way to stay one more day, contacted host again, not an issue! This place is laid out nicely if you like to cook dinner while hanging out watching movies. The 2 bedrooms are perfectly split by the bathroom. The closets have extra linens, towels, and ALL the beach gear you'd need. Chairs, floaties, beach towels. A lot of thought has been put into this home for you to enjoy your time! Read their log book! So much great info, I'm not kidding! Literally everything you need to know! We got up early to watch the sunrise, went throughout the island to visit other beaches and almost every night watched the sunset. It's really neat spot to be able to catch both. Let me tell you this: You are going to fall in love. You are going to try and figure out a way to live on this island forever. You are going to love the beaches, the people, the food, the drinks and find yourself trying to figure out how you can find conch salad back in your boring state. I joke, but this is truly a magical spot and if I'm ever so lucky enough to make it back, I want to stay at this exact spot."

Pool, Beach, kayaks, great snorkeling, calm side of the island,

10/10 Excellent

"We were met by the Kay and she had stocked our refrigerator with all the things requested. The house was the perfect size for our family of four. The access to the beach was wonderful and we took advantage of the kayaks provided as well. Jack was great at answering all of my questions….and trust me I had a lot. He gave great suggestions and resources to help the trip to so smoothly! It is truly a piece of paradise and I would definitely stay there again!!"

Room 1

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Top Cities in Long Island

Salt Pond

Our top choices for Long Island vacation homes

1. Sugar Beach Villa - Private Estate w/ 1000ft Oceanfront, Pool/Hot Tub, Concierge

2. Beach House!!! Best location-TAR BAY! Wraparound porch + hammocks!!!

3. Always Calm Beach. No Estate like this in Exuma! Brand New on protected sand bar

4. Ocean Front Property With Pool. - George Town

5. NEMO HOUSE-Luxury Beachfront on perfect Beach-Perfect for 4 couples / 2 families

6. Paradise! Private Beachfront Home w/ Pool & Beach WiFi!

7. Private and quaint 2 bedroom waterfront cottage - 10 minutes from Georgetown

8. Overwater Bungalow at Georgetown

9. Panoramic ocean view luxury villa with pool, few minutes walk to Palm Bay Beach

10. Beachside Exuma Villa newly remodeled!Great location near resorts & restaurants

11. Bay View vacation Rentals Villa # 1

12. Seaside Cottage Seabiscuit – Bonefish Flats w/Ocean Views, Family-Friendly!

13. Lady Blue Sits On Beautiful Tar Bay Beach-Features Infinity pool/Outdoor Living

14. BEACHFRONT! Best Location on Private Lazy River Sand Bar. Always Calm Water!

15. Ultimate Outdoor Living, In the Heart of Exuma, High above it all

16. Stunning ocean views, first-class accommodation - with Pool, Deck & Solar

17. OCEANFRONT, with spectacular infinity pool on Tar Bay. An Exuma paradise.

18. 11 steps to the Ocean

19. Oceanfront mansion, heated infinity pool. 6 double rooms, 11 beds can sleep 18

20. Elegant 3-Bedroom Villa with Gazebo, Deck & Breathtaking Elizabeth Harbor Views!

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Top Long Island Hotel Reviews

Peace and Plenty Resort

Great Location, beautiful home on the water,beach, pool and top amenities

Saint Francis Resort

Harbor Breeze Villas

Beachside Exuma Villa newly remodeled!Great location near resorts & restaurants

A Slice Of Tropical Paradise

Pool, Beach, kayaks, great snorkeling, calm side of the island,

OCEAN FRONT HOME WITH POOL,DOCK-STEPS TO MORIAH NATIONAL PARK

HGTV-Featured Beachfront Villa / Steps to Sand / Resort Amenities Included

Explore a world of travel with Expedia