Search Cottages in Middletown

"I’m normally not one to leave reviews but I had to for The Carriage House! Everything from the homey, relaxing feel to the great views was amazing! My friends and I wanted to extend our stay lol. We’re already planning another stay here for a summer trip! Also appreciated the host’s friendliness and ensuring we had an enjoyable experience. 10/10"

"Great host and property"

"This was the best place to celebrate my family member’s 60th! Being right on the water was amazing! We enjoyed the outdoor fire pit, the beachy air and the outdoor setting. Inside was clean and adorable. The bunk beds were much larger than appears in the picture. If you want a little getaway to enjoy the salty air, I highly recommend! The owner was very timely in getting back regarding any questions I had and was friendly. "

"Fantastic cottage. Loved the location. Clean well stocked amenities comfy beds. Would definitely stay here again "

"A perfect stay - John and his family were truly wonderful. The house is attached to thier main house, but also very private and secure. We were in town for a wedding weekend and this was the perfect spot for us - truly a beatuiful property! John was helpful in telling us about all of the local spot and supplying us with everything we needed. His wife even welcomed us with a cheese board and wine! Thanks John and family - we had a great time!"

"Lovely cottage on beautiful Lake Hayward. Very clean, comfortable accommodations and the view of the lake is stunning. The bathroom was newly renovated and the kitchen was well stocked with everything we needed to make and serve our meals. The host was very responsive and kind. Would highly recommend this property and we hope to return soon! "

"We had a lovely stay. Everything was as described on the listing and the house had everything we needed for our family. It was great to have the grill and a kitchen with all the supplies needed. The area is lovely and quiet with two small but nice private beaches within walking distance"

"Cute place, very clean"

"Stunning cottage! Great location. Well-equipped kitchen! Comfy beds. Loved the views! Truly a special place!"

"This rental was perfect. Super clean and comfy with the most amazing views. Loved that it’s right on the water with a private beach. We will definitely book this property again."

"The property was exactly as advertised and what we needed for a two night stay for a graduation. It was economical and accommodated 5 people comfortably. The interior is a bit dated, but clean. We did not spend much time at the property, so it worked well for us. The beds were a bit hard, but functional for two nights."

"Clean stunning views amazing host "