Top Vacation Homes in Rum Cay in 2026

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks

In two months

In three months

In four months

Our top choices for Rum Cay vacation homes

A covered outdoor seating area with two blue chairs facing a beach with clear turquoise water and distant islands.

1. On The Beach ~ House Marlin, with Pool!

Thompson Bay (Salt Pond)

Sharon R S.

A clear turquoise sea with a sandy beach and sparse vegetation.

2. The Point House 5 bedroom Oceanfront Villa with Cliffside Pool, Kayaks

Cat Island

Teresa W.

3. The Gatehouse – Ultra-Private Oceanfront Villa + Pool + Starlink WiFi + Kayaks

Cat Island

Heather H.

A beach with a house on the left, clear blue sky, and turquoise sea.

4. White Ocean Coral - Private Beach Villa

Port Howe, Greenwood

"The view from this location is stunning and the beach is beautiful. A few things I wish we would have know before we went: 1. When we got to the house their was no fresh water. Be sure you pick up a 5 gallon jug of water before you come to the home. 2. Due to high rains the roads were flooded so it took as quite a while to get to and from the grocery store. The location is remote so you don't want to have a flat tire. Be careful of the potholes. 3. A.J.'s convenience is closer than Gilberts...

Jetsy B.

5. Banana Wind Oceanfront Home ~ Private Beach, Snorkeling, Kayaks, Stunning Views

Cat Island

Elizabeth R.

A swimming pool with clear blue water, surrounded by palm trees and a sandy beach.

6. New Private Pool, Private Beach and Flat, Private House, what else do you need?

Whymms

mark h.

A wooden deck with two wooden lounge chairs and a railing, surrounded by lush greenery and overlooking a clear blue ocean.

7. Bahamas oceanfront paradise. 250 off if you stay 8 nights.

San salvador

Lynn B.

A beach with clear turquoise water, white sand, and a line of trees in the background.

8. Spectacular Ocean Front Home with a Beautiful Secluded Sandy Beach.

New Bight

David V.

A clear view of a beach through a natural rock arch, with turquoise water and a sandy shore visible.

9. Beachfront family home steps from the perfect secluded ocean beach.

Salt Pond

John I.

A compact kitchen with white cabinetry, a stove, a sink, and a refrigerator. There is a dining area with a chair and a table.

10. On the beach, Private path to the ocean beach.

Cat Island

A wide sandy beach with a clear blue sky and ocean.

11. Ocean View Coral - Private Beach Resort

Port Howe, Greenwood

Joanne T.

A beach with clear turquoise waters and a white sandy shore.

12. SHE SHACK for Solo Female on Fabulous Long Island

Salt Pond

13. Located in Greenwood Estates, Port Howe on Cat Island. Battery backup system!!

Port Howe

View all properties

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Apartments

Private vacation homes

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Sign in

Sign up, it's free

Top Rum Cay Hotel Reviews

Spectacular Ocean Front Home with a Beautiful Secluded Sandy Beach.

10/10 Excellent

"We had a wonderful stay at the Kiki House. The location is wonderful. The Kiki house is the only house on the beach; as a result we had the beach to ourselves the whole vacation. The Greenwood resort on the Atlantic is a short drive, as are beaches and resorts on the Caribbean side of the island. We were able to explore much of the south of Cat Island.The kayak and paddle boards were wonderful. A short paddle from the house leads to the inland waters to the west of Da Pink Chicken. Exploring these calm waters was a serene experience. Take note of the tides to ensure enough water depth to paddle.The house has a comfortable bed, and a generator for when the power goes out (this happens on small islands).We both enjoyed amazing views of the waves breaking on the rocks from the sofa when we were relaxing."

Private Beautiful Cottage with your own cove

10/10 Excellent

"We left a piece of our heart in Long Island. There are no words to describe Baywatch. Debbie and Phil are just so kind, so responsive, and they just love this island and it shows. The locals are so kind and welcoming as well! We had the best time at Gordon's Beach! Ernest and is sister are just great and their food is amazing! Find ALL the beaches! One is better than the next! Finally take a boat ride with Long Island Boat Rentals! Zoe is just wonderful and Captain Lindo will take you on a trip around the ocean that is an experience of a lifetime! We are so grateful for this trip to Long Island and can't wait to go back to Baywatch. Thank you Debbie and Phil for sharing your beautiful cottage. What a gem Baywatch and Long Island are. One quick note! If you are known to get picked on by mosquitoes bring bug spray or baby oil. The no-see-ums and mosquitoes are next level! But SO worth the trip!"

Banana Wind Oceanfront Home ~ Private Beach, Snorkeling, Kayaks, Stunning Views

10/10 Excellent

"Another wonderful trip to Banana Wind cottage on Cat Island Bahamas! Stephanie is a great host. Communication is very straightforward and easy. Harrison the caretaker is wonderful! He is also a walking history book for the island. The Banana Wind back yard is literally the ocean. Beautiful reef and snorkeling right out back. Sunsets around the corner past Da Pink Chicken or if you care to take a drive, Rolle’s Beach has a beautiful and unspoiled beach and sunsets there are magical! Just feel like I should give the normal word of caution- This is the wild and wonderful out islands. This is not a resort. The stars are amazing, close encounters with wild sea turtles, mantas and fish are a reality. There are also mosquitoes, power outages and limited dining opportunities. Meals can be provided. Just ask Harrison. We enjoy fresh fish, lobster, homemade jerked chicken and local foods like Mary’s stuffed land crabs for our daily fare. Enjoy!!"

Cape Santa Maria Beach Resort

10/10 Excellent

"12/10 amazing resort, amazing beach and wonderful staff. It was quiet and private and wonderful and clean! We loved our time there and hope to visit again. The rooms were very spacious and clean. The amenities for the room and beach were so plentiful and unexpected! What a wonderful stay!"

New Private Pool, Private Beach and Flat, Private House, what else do you need?

10/10 Excellent

"Our stay in Long Island, Bahamas was absolutely fantastic! Erik was an exceptional host who communicated with us every step of the way, making the entire experience seamless. Karin, the house manager, met us at the airport and guided us to the house, which was a wonderful personal touch. Mr. Percy also provided excellent communication and had a great rental car waiting for us when we arrived.The house exceeded our expectations. It was beautifully equipped with everything we needed, especially the spacious kitchen, which had every item imaginable for preparing meals. The infinity pool was incredible, the beds were very comfortable, and the home was the perfect place to relax after exploring the island.A special thank you to Zoe from Long Island Boat Rentals, who made boating effortless by delivering our boat directly to the house and securing it to the mooring ball behind the property. We spent our days discovering the island's stunning beaches by both car and boat.We especially enjoyed dining at Tiny's Restaurant, found an excellent fresh fish market near Clarence Town, and highly recommend visiting Mr. Watson at Gordon's Restaurant on the southern tip of the island for the breathtaking views alone.This was truly an unforgettable vacation, and we wouldn't hesitate to rent from Erik again. We had an amazing time and can't wait to return!"

Room 1

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Rum Cay vacation homes

1. On The Beach ~ House Marlin, with Pool!

2. The Point House 5 bedroom Oceanfront Villa with Cliffside Pool, Kayaks

3. The Gatehouse – Ultra-Private Oceanfront Villa + Pool + Starlink WiFi + Kayaks

4. White Ocean Coral - Private Beach Villa

5. Banana Wind Oceanfront Home ~ Private Beach, Snorkeling, Kayaks, Stunning Views

6. New Private Pool, Private Beach and Flat, Private House, what else do you need?

7. Bahamas oceanfront paradise. 250 off if you stay 8 nights.

8. Spectacular Ocean Front Home with a Beautiful Secluded Sandy Beach.

9. Beachfront family home steps from the perfect secluded ocean beach.

10. On the beach, Private path to the ocean beach.

11. Ocean View Coral - Private Beach Resort

12. SHE SHACK for Solo Female on Fabulous Long Island

13. Located in Greenwood Estates, Port Howe on Cat Island. Battery backup system!!

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Top Rum Cay Hotel Reviews

Spectacular Ocean Front Home with a Beautiful Secluded Sandy Beach.

Private Beautiful Cottage with your own cove

On The Beach ~ House Marlin, with Pool!

Banana Wind Oceanfront Home ~ Private Beach, Snorkeling, Kayaks, Stunning Views

Cape Santa Maria Beach Resort

The Point House Luxury 5 bedroom Oceanfront Villa with Cliffside Pool, Kayaks

New Private Pool, Private Beach and Flat, Private House, what else do you need?

The Gatehouse – Ultra-Private Oceanfront Villa + Pool + Starlink WiFi + Kayaks

Stella Maris Resort Club

Explore a world of travel with Expedia