Find Hotels with a Pool in Shelter Island, NY

Plan, book, stay with confidence

Be picky

Search almost a million properties worldwide

Treat yourself

Save instantly and earn perks with One Key

Learn about One Key

Change your mind

Book hotels with free cancellation

Check availability on Shelter Island Hotels with a Pool

Pick from Shelter Island Hotels with a Pool and compare room rates, reviews, and availability. Most hotels are fully refundable.

Frequently asked questions

What is there to see and do in Shelter Island?

Surround yourself with nature at Sunset Beach and Crescent Beach. Discover sights such as Gardiner’s Bay Country Club, Shelter Island Historical Society, and Havens House during your stay.

When is the best time to book a hotel with a pool in Shelter Island?

You may want to think about an accommodation that has an outdoor pool if you will be visiting Shelter Island in the hottest months of August, July, or September when the average temp is 70°F. Lodging offering an indoor pool may be what you want if you come to town during the coldest months of January, February, or March when the average temperature is 38°F.