Search Inns in Upper Matecumbe Key

"The staff was friendly and laid back. The resort was absolutely beautiful! "

"i,m 5"10 and the shower in room 135 is way to low. at 71 years young to go out the back door is way to hard to open.BAR; Bar is to high,the foot stand are to low and the lights at the bar in front of the TVs makes no sense.There are not enough lounge chairs on the beach and not enough of the cabanas(there only 3).Dinner was great except no bread or salad with the meal for the price.And you need to pack the bocce ball court so you can actually enjoy it."

"I loved it "

"We stayed in the green cottage (didn't take photos of inside). Location is fabulous and sunrises are beautiful. Room was clean upon arrival. However, it did not look as nice as the website. Bathroom was very small. Little counter top space and no tub (we didn't care about that). Bedroom smaller too. We stayed four nights and elected to not have our room cleaned on one day. However, it was not cleaned on the other days even though staff said it was on the list. The Tiki Bar does not serve alcohol. We had to order our drinks at the sister resort, Amara Cay and have them delivered. Not sure if we missed that on the website, but definitely disappointed. Enjoyed drinks and apps at the Amara Cay Tiki Bar."

"Wonderful property! Every staff member was friendly, the room was clean and spacious, breakfast was cooked to order as we ate outside overlooking the water. We had a small dog and she was welcome everywhere. I would definitely stay here again!"

"Loved it "

"Lime Tree Bay is split into two areas and we were away from the main site, which is only a 3 minute walk away. We would have preferred the main site, however our room was across the highway. The only nearby dining option is the bar adjacent to the main property, which served a good selection of food. Our room was very good, clean and located above a second swimming pool. "

"I recently stayed at this hotel in Key Largo, and overall, it’s a mixed experience with some clear highlights. The biggest plus is how genuinely pet-friendly the property is. Not just “allowed,” but truly welcoming—something that’s rare and very appreciated. The atmosphere is incredibly peaceful and calm, perfect for disconnecting and unwinding. Valet parking is not only efficient, but the team is also genuinely kind and helpful—one of the standout aspects of the stay. That said, the property itself feels a bit worn. Not terrible, but definitely showing its age. The overall concept leans heavily toward a “do-it-yourself” experience: you need to pick up your own towels, get your own ice, and handle small things that you’d normally expect to be taken care of in a more full-service hotel. Another downside is the lack of guidance at check-in. No one really explains how the amenities work or what’s available—you’re essentially left to figure everything out on your own. Service overall is average. The staff is polite, but nothing stands out—no real sense of going above and beyond. The beach service, in particular, is almost nonexistent. If you’re expecting to order drinks or food while relaxing by the water, you’ll likely be disappointed. The restaurant is good—solid, enjoyable meals—but not particularly memorable. It does the job without trying to impress. For a stay that cost over $2,000 for three nights, you naturally expect a higher level of service and attention to detail."

"Everything was amazing exactly what we expected. No surprises great staff. We really enjoyed it!"