Search Vacation Homes in West Liberty

"Very nice little cottage, walking distance to water, nice neighborhood tavern "LuLu's on the Lake" Making a good recovery from recent tornado-neighbors helping neighbors! I would stay here again!"

"On our way to Indiana for the Indy 500 and stayed for the night. Very clean home! Had everything you could possibly need. WAY better than a hotel!! Hot tub was fantastic! Hot and ready to go. Kids absolutely loved it! Only critique would be a second shower because all of us needed one before we left but we made it work. Beds were very comfortable and plenty of places to sleep and rest. Felt very safe with the security system in place. Thank you for such a great home! Would highly recommend!"

"We booked the house to watch the eclipse, and it was honestly the perfect place for our quick trip. Gary was incredibly open and communicative, and we really enjoyed watching the eclipse from the backyard and the sunset over the water. Thanks Gary!"

"Love the place just as described. Awesome back patio area was perfect for entertaining."

"We aren't far from home so I didn't pack much for the kids to do. Our kids were very happy to see a video game console (old school, which kept their attention longer than even our Switch at home), many board games, kids books, legos, and even stuffies. There was plenty of space for all 5 of us plus our dogs. The beds and pull out couch are all comfortable. They provided plenty of amenities including a book with all the local favorite places. We spent hours at the beach, took lots of walks,...

"Beautiful place very peaceful fish not bad"

"Enjoyed our stay and the location was nice. Beds could have been a little more comfortable. Needs an a/c unit in each room. Was tough to sleep at night the doors closed. Good thing was we had a nice weather week."

"We really loved this house. It met all our needs and then some. Very clean and the kitchen had everything I needed to cook. We did need to contact the manager of this place and she responded immediately. Met one of the neighbors and she was very nice. We asked her for recommendations on eating places and loved the place (Titlted Hilton) she recommended. We hope to visit this place again."

"Family Weekend! The whole house and property is wonderful! There is everything there to make it so much fun. The outside is beautiful! The house is very nice and provides any thing you need. We had a wonderful weekend and will return again. Thank you for sharing your beautiful home!"

"What an incredible property! One of the best rental properties we’ve ever rented. From the vintage and new decor, well placed lighting, and comfortable EVERYTHING! The linens, bedding and bathroom were quite luxurious. The panoramic views from the front bay of windows made it so worth it. While we weren’t able to use the beautiful patio due to the weather, I’m sure we would have enjoyed that space as well. I highly recommend this property!"

"We had a wonderful time and it was so nice"

"Had a great boys weekend spent fishing"

"We really enjoyed our stay here, it was perfect for our family weekend at Indian Lake. Close to grocery and things to do highly recommend."

"We had a wonderful time on Orchard Island! Such a friendly area. Our trip was to see the eclipse and we were not disappointed. We would love to come back in the summer and actually use the lake! We were saddened by all the tornado damage in the area but Chris was so helpful about keeping us updated on the house and businesses in the area. We were happy to come and support the area."

"The staff of this property was well above reproach. My daughter forgot one of her stuff animals at the site and they offered to ship it to us. This is the second time we’ve stayed at this particular cottage and we have enjoyed it so much that we will definitely be back, all the neighbors were super nice. It is definitely worth the time and energy. We spent to save it and we will definitely be back. "

"The house was very clean. The host was quick to respond and very kind. We enjoyed sitting on the porch."

"My husband, in laws and our 2 year old son and nephew had the best time at Rick and Christine’s home. The directions to get into the house were clear, and the house was available many hours before scheduled check in. The house is lovely, with two bedrooms, a bathroom and a bonus game room where the toddlers slept in their pack and plays. We appreciated all of the small touches from the sweet welcome card and bubbles, the coffee, and the wonderful assortment of games. We come yearly to Indian...

"We had a great stay!! The only downsides were not having access to a dock and the bathroom configuration. Owners were responsive and accommodating! We had such a great time!!!"

"My second time staying here. It is perfect for my weekend fishing get aways. Location is good and neighbors are friendly and they let you use a boat dock if one is available. I will continue to book here."