Find all hotels by Best Western in Fishers Island, NY from AED 461

"Room was almost spotless. Larger than most. Decent coffee. Nice shuttle to the casino"

"Great location to all Mystic activities and great room for a family of 5. "

"Our family of four stayed for 3 nights in a two bedroom suite with ocean views. We booked it last minute for spring break. Overall, we had an amazing time and enjoyed our stay despite the cold temps. The room was clean. I saw no obvious signs of aging of furniture, fittings and walls - a huge plus given the volume of people it must see. We chose to have breakfasts, lunches and one evening's dinner outside of the resort. The only area I thought they could have done better is the consistency of the communication and countenance of the staff. Front desk was excellent - smiles, eye contact and clear communication. Cleaner was happy, smiles and positive. Gigi's maitre d' was polite and prompt but we're out of New York, it'll be nice to have some warmth through a smile and eye contact. Similarly, while one evening's waiter, Felix, was phenomenal in his ability to connect professionally with us, the next night's waiter did not. I can understand that they must see a variety of individuals every day and it can wear on their emotions (perhaps some individuals are rude to them?) but they are in customer facing roles and each new table is an opportunity to bring some warmth and enjoyment to a new customer's experience. We'd go again and adjust our expectations of Gigi's dining experience. "

"This hotel is so much fun! From all the nautical touches to the kid entertainment and pool we really enjoyed ourselves. We also had a wonderful experience at the restaurant on the property, the clam chowder, rib eye and one drunk punch were Devine. "

"The staff were very friendly, rooms were nice"

"Upon arrival, the staff were so friendly and the hotel clean and cute. The lobby area has beautiful art and it’s very inviting. The room was clean and had a working fridge and iron. There was no microwave (for those needing one). My room didn’t have a jacuzzi tub but the shower was amazing! The staff at checkout was super friendly. This hotel is only a few miles away from Foxwoods Casino. We didn’t get a chance to utilize the shuttle but they have one that makes frequent trips back and forth throughout the day and I believe it stops around midnight. I would definitely stay here again and recommend others to stay. It’s was a wonderful experience."

"The kitchen was perfect, only thing missing was utensils. There is a local store on the way to the manor to pick some of those staples up from. "

"Somehow I missed that they did not have a fridge or coffeemaker. When we went to breakfast it was mostly gone and no one was around refilling it, so we waited and then ended up going elsewhere and paying for breakfast. The blinds did not close all the way and our room faced street lights so our room lit up all night. Pillows were good but bed was hard unfortunately. I have a broken foot and when they asked what floor we wanted we said the third so as we didn't hear feet above us as we tried to sleep and they gave us the furthest room away from the elevator. Kind of weird, and didn't even mention that there was a stairwell on that further end of the building that we could have driven to to go up instead of walking three long hallways with all of our stuff. We had hoped to use the shuttle to Moheghan, but when we got there there was sign that it was only friday and saturday (we were there on a thursday). I was disappointed as it didn't say that on their website just that a shuttle was available. So we ended up paying for Uber both ways. If I had known ahead of time I would have planned different. The shuttle was a big draw and the closeness to the casino. Not sure we will stay there again. I'm not sure if all Microtel's are like this (no fridge, no coffeemaker, etc...) but that's also a drawback."

"The breakfast was good. The heater in the room made a lot of noise and smelled. Otherwise it was close to Foxwoods. No pool which we were looking forward to but didn't really check into it when we booked it"