It was all wonderful, but the thing that stood out most was the incredible staff. Josh, in particular, went so far out of his way to be kind and helpful to a couple of newbies (us) who had entirely too many questions and had done far too little research about the island before arriving. Thanks, Josh! Oh, and the food! If you try nothing else, have the seafood chowder. The best I've had anywhere, and I'm a chowder fanatic. We will definitely be back once we get a few other bucket list trips out of the way. Highly recommended if you want a truly laid-back vacation without all the hype and crowds found at other resorts on other islands.