Find hotels near Preacher's Cave,

"This is a really nice, larger house for Spanish Wells. Very clean upon arrival and the house manager was great about arranging transport from the airport and overall very responsive. "

"Air conditioning excellent. Clean and well located. "

"immaculate property with friendly efficient staff. stayed in a newly renovated briland room which was beautiful. food was delicious (although the continental breakfast is a bit sparse). beach is incredible. so wide and soft like baby powder and you can walk forever on beach or in water which is shallow and clean. there is a little putting green, tennis and pickleball, gym with sauna and ice plunge. wish they had a spa. a wonderful place. "

"We (3 couples) stayed here 10/29 to 11/08/25. House exceeded our expectations. Kitchen had everything you could need. Bedrooms were spacious. Three bedrooms, two en-suite and one with bathroom right across hallway. Covered back porch with plenty of seating and oceanview. Two other separate seatings areas overlooking the beach. Beach chairs for sitting in the sand. Tons of floats, paddle board, and kayak. Our flight out got canceled due to government shutdown. Had to stay four more nights before we could get out. Paradise was already booked for the coming week. However, Bonnie called around to other property owners and was able to secure us a place to stay. That was a lifesaver.Spanish Wells is very laid back. Beach is stunning. Easy to get around on golf cart. 10 minutes ferry ride from Eleuthera.Highly recommend Paradise Beach Cottage!"

"Wonderful"

"Review for Tingum Village, Harbour Island My wife and I had a smooth and pleasant check-in at Tingum Village. We were given a wonderful room with a comfortable king-size bed, and it set the tone for a fantastic stay. The staff were exceptional—helpful, friendly, and always willing to go the extra mile. This isn’t a 5-star hotel, but it delivered exactly what we were looking for: comfort, charm, and genuine hospitality. It felt like a true home away from home. Thank you to all the staff for the warm welcome and for making our stay memorable. Rory & Rehana Armstrong"

"Beautiful place friendly people"

"FABULOUS HOME! We absolutely loved our stay here. April was a fantastic host and Brandi who picked us up from the ferry was a dream! We will be booking here again!"

"Excellent place to stay, we stayed 6 nights. April was an excellent host. She also arranged two full day boat excursions for us with them, and we had an amazing time. Would definitely stay/recommend again. "