Find 2 Star Hotels in Shelter Island, NY from AED91

"Amazing hotel. "

"Overall, this was a very good experience. The room was clean, including the bed and the bathroom. Everything worked as expected, and there was plenty of hot water for showering. The TV and the WiFi worked well. It felt safe. The property is convenient to all mid-shoreline activities. It was very quiet except for one instance in which there was a family with an exuberant toddler staying in the room right above me; I notified the desk person and he took care of it right away. It's a good budget...

"Excellent visit, had everything we needed. Super clean, exceptionally comfortable. "

"We enjoyed our stay and felt it was good value for the area. "

"Very quiet. Easy access to 95"

"Great location and everyone was super friendly! "

"This was a great location for my weekend of activities. The room was clean and had all amenities I needed. "

"Property was recently renovated. Clean rooms and area around. Only issue was a mold smell in room. Overall the place was good."

"Pleasant easy . Renovated mid century motel with a lovely pool and restaurant/bar. Walk in and out of town. To the port and back. Ferry close by"

"Great location"

"It was a perfect relaxing weekend with my husband, and I am definitely coming back. So clean!!!"

"nice lodging view of ocean, all amenities, clean, comfortable bed"

"Staff was so quick & responsive, beautiful grounds & the apartment suite was perfect with 2 kids!"

"Great service. "

"Beautiful serene property. Lovely stay. "

"Excellent as always ♥️"

"Great location and the owner is simply the best! She gave me insights and tips about the area that were useful. Other patrons were nice and courteous. I recommend this hotel and I will be back "

"This place was quiet and beautiful. It was a super short walk to the beach. Staff was friendly but a tad unorganized when I got to the desk. Still really kind though. All in all I loved my stay and will be revisiting in the future."

"Enjoyed our Stay. Beautiful view."

"Perfect for our quick family getaway. "