Search Apartments in Shelter Island

"The host had so many special touches to make this place a wonderful spot to stay. She had little snacks in the kitchen, with coffee and tea in the cupboard. There was half-and-half and the refrigerator, which we really appreciated. The towels in the bathroom were folded like you were in a special hotel. There was also lovely soap, shampoo and conditioner. Due to the cold temperature in the teens, she actually purchased some space heaters to make sure we were warm. Although there was a second...

"Loved our stay! Perfect location and the place was very clean."

"Studio was perfect and grounds of property were breaking. Would definitely stay there again. Got to enjoy Montauk and have a beautiful place to stay."

"My family and I visited for 3 nights in late April, and this was the perfect place for us! Conveniently located in walking distance to downtown Greenport, with ample street parking, and the unit was modern, clean and spacious. The home itself is beautiful and with a lovely, well-cared-for garden. Definitely recommend!"

"The location is absolutely beautiful. The apartment was clean and looked exactly like the pictures. The host was helpful and was able to communicate with me as needed. We would stay there again in a heartbeat!"

"We loved our stay! Apartment was perfect. Upstairs views to the harbor were lovely to wake up to. Easy, quick walk to town and restaurant. We will be sure to go back and stay there again."

"We enjoyed our stay at Mary’s little cottage that is well situated to get to everything in town. The happy surprise is that it is surrounded by flowers and tomato plants. The place had everything we needed. It is small but perfect for two. We’d love to come back."

"We were in town to celebrate thanksgiving. Nice cozy 1 bedroom apartment. 5 minute drive to town."

"We enjoyed Manny and Amal’s place. It was a short walk from the beach. Beautiful garden and very welcoming hosts. It is a basement apartment which kept it cool on hot days. The kitchen had more of a toaster oven than an oven but otherwise was usable with some creativity. The grill was great. Having only one key was tricky but we worked it out. A keypad entry would be a great upgrade. We were welcomed with homemade cookies and would definitely stay again."

"We had a good time. Great location."

"We had a wonderful stay at this property! Very clean, just steps to the beach and close to everything we love in the Hamptons!"

"Best affordable hotel in Montauk"

"Good family friendly resort! Hope it’s a heated pool.. Easy Check-out before 11:00 am!"

"Very nice location and nice condo"