Find Historic Hotels in Fire Island, NY

"The room was nice, and the kitchen was fine, but I got food poisoning from eating the food served by the hotel. I am certain of this because I only ate hotel food the day I got sick and the day before I got sick. My husband also had food poisoning the day after we arrived, though I am not certain that it was due to food prepared by the hotel. Needless to say, the fact that each of us was sick for 3 days negates any of the pisitive attributes of the hotel for us and we will most certainly never stay there again. "

"First room - no AC. Temperature was 82 degrees. Went down to the desk and they said they'd send maintanace. After half an hour, followed up with a call and was told they had quite a few maintanace issues ahead of ours. Eventually transferred to a second room where the AC did not work, but at least the temperature in the room was 72 degrees. TV did not work. No hot water in the shower. Was scheduled for two nights, but left after one. This was unreal."

"WiFi was hard to get into, room was decent "

"We had a great experience at this hotel. Food was great, staff was great accommodations are great!"

"Everything was fine except for the mattress. Terribly soft; left with a very bad backache!"

"Clean rooms"

"The first floor atrium is beautiful. So light and open. The room was clean and comfortable."

"One of the treadmills needed to be serviced."

"The breakfast was very good. The pastries were all fresh and there were many choices of coffee."