Search Vacation Homes in Fishers Island

"The parking was free that’s the only good thing about this place. The beds are so uncomfortable there’s not many charging ports the room it’s self is ok very dated had a weird smell."

"Montauk Manor is one of the most magnificent historic properties I’ve ever stayed in. The breathtaking views and stunning sunsets from the property are simply incredible. It’s a highly recommended place to stay when you’re visiting Montauk."

"Liked the room overall. Clean. Bed comfortable. It was missing the usual amenities like a light on the desk. Note pad & pad. Extra blankets and pillows. Had trouble regulating the heat in the room. Why is toilet paper so far behind the toilet?? Night light in bathroom."

"It was okay. Definitely I will book my next trip there."

"Hotel was clean and nice. Staff was very good. Bar and restaurant open late which was nice."

"We checked into our room and went out after a few minutes to Foxwoods casino. When we returned at around 930pm we discovered we did not have a remote controll for our TV. They brought one to us. The refrigerator was not cleaned a ice mask was left in the freezer and the bathroom door did not close appropriately. There was no body wash in the shower. Our coffee maker has a layer or dust on top of it. Breakfast took about 20 minutes to be waited on and the pancakes i ordered were not served with the strawberries and powdered sugar as the menu read and it took 25 minutes or so for them to come out. The waiter never came back to check on us and instead of asking how everything was. He asked "if we were all set" no have a good day...nothing.... this was the worst experience we have had at this hotel. "

"Clean room. Get what you paid for. Solid hotel for a night"

"We had a great time there that we was there for almost a week and the staff was sensational accommodated us for whatever we need it"

"Yes"