Search Vacation Homes in Fishers Island

"Great stay, charming cottage, hope to return"

"Great Location! Within walking distance to all the sights in Mystic!"

"Check-in was easy. We were delighted when we entered to find an immaculate home, beautifully furnished, with everything clean & easy to find. Very easy access to local attractions. "

"The rooms were all equally size with King size beds so it’s perfect for 4 couples. House is warm, clean and comfortable. Would love to come back during warmer months to enjoy the deck and all the house has to offer. Thank you"

"This was a great house for our annual cousins' trip! The first level has all of the bedrooms, living room and kitchen. I will flag that you could hear everything from the bedrooms that was happening in the living rooms so may not be the best fit for light sleepers. Big, beautiful backyard!! "

"The property was perfect for our trip. Wonderful stay and amazing contact with the hosttess. "

"We had a wonderful time! Nick was incredibly good with communication and the house was incredible. A wonderful place to stay to celebrate and enjoy the casino's nearby. Also highly recommended the driving range right down the road. Super quaint bit a fun break during the day! Would highly recommended. "

"Great location for family gathering! Casino, shopping, restaurants, historic area, great fenced backyard and playhouse in addition to an amazing well appointed home that had plenty of room for our blended family. This is situated right off the green and very convenient! The down side to this is that from the front rooms at night you may hear traffic, so light sleepers should get the rooms (there are 8 with 1 very small tandem bedroom) farther back in the house. We will definitely go back!"

"Loved the area. Loved the house. Very clean "

"Great little welcoming home. Nicely appointed with the little amenities that m am me it feel like home. "

"We found this home a perfect combination of being able to get away but also convenient to restaurants, stores, and activities. The view could not be beat and the house was clean and comfortable."

"Just hubby & I. Great fireplace and deck with very clean bubbly hot tub. Comfy king-sized bed. Kitchen was clean & functional with basics. Backyard appeared larger in pictures. Rental could use extra couch in living room to comfortably fit eight ppl. The living room couch is just for sitting, appears larger in pictures. Couch is"