Top Cottages in Long Island in 2026

A coastal landscape with a clear blue sea, a sandy beach, and a small island with buildings.

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks

In two months

In three months

In four months

Our top choices for Long Island cottages

1. Buttercup Family Cottage beautiful beach, great snorkeling spot across the road

Georgetown

Micah S.

2. Escape from the daily stresses of life to this tranquil beach cottage.

Williams Town - Tropic of Cancer Beach

Gina D.

3. Private Beautiful Cottage with your own cove

Long Island

Jamie B.

4. The Cozy Cottage comes 10% discount at TwinConnection Floating Bar.

Emerald Bay

Stevisha

5. Secluded beach house on Hooper's Bay, Great Exuma, The Bahamas

George Town

Mary S.

6. Lovely 2-bedroom cottage with sea views located in Exuma, Bahamas

Hartswell

"We had an amazing stay at Mangrove Haven in Exuma. The location truly couldn’t have been better—perfectly situated between Georgetown and Tropic of Cancer Beach, making it easy to explore both while still enjoying a peaceful, relaxing setting.The house itself was incredibly well equipped with everything we needed for a comfortable stay. From the kitchen essentials to the thoughtful extras, it really felt like a home away from home. You can tell the owners put a lot of care into making sure...

Angela L.

7. Cabanya Azul with view of Atlantic and small Beach within walking distance

Buckley's Settlement

Marvin D.

8. Hoopers Bay Villas

George Town

"This is a place to put your head down and that's about it. Small cottage that has many miles on it. Beds and bedding were old and uncomfortable. Blanket consisted of a sleeping bag. Showers backed up into the tub. Air conditioner leaked onto the living room floor. It rained hard while we were there. had some time where we could not go anywhere. TV is broken. Looks like the coax cable was yanked out of the back. Back window was broken with a piece of plastic and tape over it. One...

Anonymous traveler

View all properties

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Apartments

Villas

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Top Long Island Hotel Reviews

Hideaways Exuma

8/10 Good

"Clean room"

OCEAN FRONT HOME WITH POOL,DOCK-STEPS TO MORIAH NATIONAL PARK

10/10 Excellent

"We rent properties a couple of times per year in the Exumas for about 8 years now and we haven't had a terrible experience yet. If we grade them all we would have to say the it was unanimous that this property is the cream of the crop. We rent small boats each time so we need a dock otherwise you'll have to return the boat and pick it up every day and that's not condusive to a fun and easy vacay. We purposely rent small skiffs so we can get to some treasure beaches that not many people have access to and they are BUCKET LIST beaches. This property is the closest to all our secret spots. Outstanding views, a beach in the back yard and a pool as well. The property has just about every large or small amenity you can think of. We lacked nothing. Angelique was a doll. I'm not a fan of giving nothing but 5 stars to a place because there's always a little hiccup here and there but not here. Bring your bikini and swim shorts. Nothing else is needed. Thanks to the staff/team for a spectacular vacation with my wife and kids. Very grateful!!!!!"

Great Location, beautiful home on the water,beach, pool and top amenities

10/10 Excellent

"The property and home were exactly as pictured and described. There was so much to do at the house with the pool, dock, kayaks and paddle boards, huge screened in porch, and beachfront for our family with 2 teenagers. Communication prior to our trip, as well as while we were there, was very attentive and helpful regarding the home, activities and restaurants on the island, making sure we’re were happy with our stay. They were even able to have the house stocked with all of our groceries and drinks the day of our arrival.If we are able to come back to vacation in beautiful Exuma (which I hope we do) we would absolutely stay at Jack’s Island House again!"

Saint Francis Resort

10/10 Excellent

"This was the best experience I had at The Bahamas. From touching down at the airport, to check in, to check out. Everything was so well planned on behalf of the resort. I’m so amazed. It was so relaxing and I wish I could stay here forever. Thank you everyone here. I can’t wait to come back again!!"

A Slice Of Tropical Paradise

10/10 Excellent

"This truly is a slice of paradise! This was our first trip to Exuma to celebrate our 25th anniversary. This home is perfectly placed, stocked and cleaned!When I first booked, I reached out to the host to add a day, no issue! Then halfway through our stay, my husband and I found a way to stay one more day, contacted host again, not an issue! This place is laid out nicely if you like to cook dinner while hanging out watching movies. The 2 bedrooms are perfectly split by the bathroom. The closets have extra linens, towels, and ALL the beach gear you'd need. Chairs, floaties, beach towels. A lot of thought has been put into this home for you to enjoy your time! Read their log book! So much great info, I'm not kidding! Literally everything you need to know! We got up early to watch the sunrise, went throughout the island to visit other beaches and almost every night watched the sunset. It's really neat spot to be able to catch both. Let me tell you this: You are going to fall in love. You are going to try and figure out a way to live on this island forever. You are going to love the beaches, the people, the food, the drinks and find yourself trying to figure out how you can find conch salad back in your boring state. I joke, but this is truly a magical spot and if I'm ever so lucky enough to make it back, I want to stay at this exact spot."

Ocean Front Property With Pool. - George Town

10/10 Excellent

"This is our 2nd stay and we love SeaBreeze lodge. The view is amazing!!! This side of the island makes great use of the kayaks and paddleboards. You can kayak to a little island during high tide. You can walk out in the middle of the flats during low tide. You can get a float and enjoy the calm water. You can kayak right to a blue hole. The roads are a little rough to get to the house but rent an SUV and go slower and you will be completely fine. We had everything to cook meals and there is a grill for use as well. The pool is wonderful to have as well. The outside area is so relaxing. The host and Joanes are extremely responsive and helpful with whatever questions or needs arise. We love it here and will be back. Thank you for a wonderful week stay in Exuma."

Frequently asked questions

Why book your cottage in Long Island with Expedia?

Reserving a cottage in Long Island is as easy as deciding on your travel dates and picking your ideal place for a getaway in the outdoors. From upscale retreats to inexpensive stays and cottages that have conveniences like a kitchen, Expedia has something for all traveler styles. As for epic deals? We've have them as well!

How can I find cheap cottages in Long Island?

The simplest way to uncover cheap cottages in Long Island is with Expedia's handy filter tool. Narrow down your search by star rating, amenities and budget to grab awesome prices in just a few keystrokes.

Room 1

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Long Island cottages

1. Buttercup Family Cottage beautiful beach, great snorkeling spot across the road

2. Escape from the daily stresses of life to this tranquil beach cottage.

3. Private Beautiful Cottage with your own cove

4. The Cozy Cottage comes 10% discount at TwinConnection Floating Bar.

5. Secluded beach house on Hooper's Bay, Great Exuma, The Bahamas

6. Lovely 2-bedroom cottage with sea views located in Exuma, Bahamas

7. Cabanya Azul with view of Atlantic and small Beach within walking distance

8. Hoopers Bay Villas

9. On hilltop with pool. Only 400 feet down to waterfront, dock & kayaks.

10. Ixora East - Beach access with great snorkeling spot

11. Blue Hole Lodge - Bonefish Heaven with Blue Hole in Backyard

12. Modern Beachfront Cottage

13. Serene and Tranquil ocean view cottage

14. Exuma Sol - Stunning Views from this Oceanfront Beach Cottage

15. Plumbago - Paradise in the Bahamas with Ocean views

16. Intimate Luxury on Bahamas Best Beach - Blue Point Cottage Beach House

17. Cottage At Dean's Blue Hole - Walking Distance To The Blue Hole!

18. The Turquoise @ Hoopers Bay Beach

19. Beautiful Beach Eco-Cottage on Stocking Island

20. Ixora West - Views over Elizabeth harbor, beach access across the road.

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Top Long Island Hotel Reviews

Hideaways Exuma

Peace and Plenty Resort

OCEAN FRONT HOME WITH POOL,DOCK-STEPS TO MORIAH NATIONAL PARK

Great Location, beautiful home on the water,beach, pool and top amenities

Saint Francis Resort

Harbor Breeze Villas

Beachside Exuma Villa newly remodeled!Great location near resorts & restaurants

A Slice Of Tropical Paradise

Ocean Front Property With Pool. - George Town

Frequently asked questions

Explore a world of travel with Expedia