Find Hotels with a Pool in Long Island

"We are return guests and love it. The food was amazing at both the Pineapple Grill and Chef Pietros. Staff very friendly and accommodating. Now the negatives - the rooms in the waterfront building NEED to be renovated desperately. The showers are disgusting and ours had red an black mildew growing. Also, who can reach a safe that is 6 ft off the ground? My wife couldn’t and I had to pull a chair up to it each time I needed to get in. Last, the Topaz restaurant always seemed short staffed. Hopefully, by the time we visit next year these things will be corrected."

"great pool clean room with a great view helpful staff "

"Incredible View! Staff was amazing! Food and entertainment was great! Would definitely stay here again!"

"The property is amazingly beautiful. It is rustic and not for anyone with mobility challenges but the views in every direction are breathtaking. We had an opportunity to stay in a bay-view pool cottage for the first half of the trip and a sunset-view pool cottage for the second half. Both views were great, but we slightly preferred the bay view just because the view had more character. Both cottages were rustic but very well done. The double outdoor show was so amazing! We just got back (early May) and it was HOT and Humid. Most staff were nice, but some were really nice and some were not very friendly. Overall however it was a great experience. Food was very good and for a single restaurant they offered a nice variety."

"quiet close to the beach well cared for"

"Amazing such a beautiful well kept place. Loved everything about it just wish there was more night time entertainment "

"Excellent resort. Wonderful staff. Unique and contemporary features. Highlight: Prickly Pear Island. "

"Loved our stay. A few steps from the beach, the water & sand is perfect! Good food places & grocery nearby. The team working at the property was lovely & it was my birthday. They helped my partner create a special day for me. I know old reviews say there are rude staff - never once had a negative experience. No doubt, I would stay here again! Thanks so much for a great stay! "

"The setting was wonderful, the staff were very friendly and the food and drink plentiful although the accommodation was slightly tired. Very good value."