"Leaving five stars, because I really liked this hotel, and would like to see it succeed.
My wife and I stayed here for one week from Apr. 28 to May. 5.
The hotel itself is a historic stone building. Purportedly the building has been around since the 1600s, when it was used as a company office and sleeping quarters by the Danish West India Company. The building was recently given a 17 million dollar renovation with repairs, replacements, and additions to turn it into a functional hotel. Many original pieces of the building are thankfully preserved, such as the old stone staircases.
There is a small piano bar but it was not open during our stay and only open during peak seasons.
We enjoyed the beautiful garden-walled saltwater pool, the free guest laundry, the historic feel and the walkabilty to downtown Christiansted. We found the staff friendly and helpful.
We wished there was more history immersion. It felt sparse.
The main issue we had were that the hotel is built directly across the street from "Levels" nightclub. This nightclub played music so loud that it shook our room and we could hear every single note. The nightclub did not stop and ran until 4am on friday and saturday, and 12am on sunday. Drunken patrons filled the street and were also screaming and yelling. We got almost zero sleep these nights. It was miserable. I had no idea there was a nightclub when I booked. The front desk / hotel manager did their best make it up to me for the issue and I am thankful."