Top Cottages in Sullivan County in 2026

A multi-tiered waterfall surrounded by dense forest.

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks

In two months

In three months

In four months

Top Cities in Sullivan County

A moss-covered log with rocks and a stream.

Our top choices for Sullivan County cottages

1. CREEKSIDE COTTAGE located on Route 87 close to the Loyalsock Creek.

Williamsport

Elaine L.

2. Large, charming lake cottage nestled in the heart of our private lake community.

Eagles Mere

Barbara V.

3. Muncy Vacation Rental w/ Deck & Views

Muncy

Sabrina

4. The Katonah House at Lake Mokoma - Pet Friendly with Lake, Beach, & Boat Access.

Laporte

Anthony R.

5. Owl's Nest - Treehouse -2mi. from falls trailhead

Sweet Valley

Kenneth B.

AED 1,597 total

includes taxes & fees

8 Sep - 9 Sep

6. Eagles Mere lakefront 6-bedroom 3-bath cottage

Eagles Mere

Mark

7. BullFrog cottage, Harveys Lake, PA - Spectacular lakefront presence and view!

Harveys Lake

josh a.

8. "Timber Acres" is nestled in the woods with private pond in Eagles Mere

Eagles Mere

josephine n.

View all properties

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Apartments

Private vacation homes

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Top Sullivan County Hotel Reviews

Quality Inn Bloomsburg

10/10 Excellent

"Everything was excellent"

Days Inn by Wyndham Williamsport

8/10 Good

"The things I liked: it was cheaper than other hotels. It was convenient to my route. It was reasonably quiet, although I could hear my neighbors quite clearly when they made soft noises. There were lots of pillows, so I could sleep sitting up, when the mattress was too uncomfortable to sleep on. Things I didn’t like: there was a side door near my room that was supposed to be locked, but the latch didn’t work. The toilet failed intermittently, though it sometimes worked – enough for me to get down what I needed to get down with repeated flushing. The mattress was quite uncomfortable. There were no USB outlets. The receptionist could be reached by phone, but she was not at the desk most of the time. The continental breakfast lacked gluten-free alternatives and protein."

Outdoorsman’s Paradise

10/10 Excellent

"I was visiting my dad and needed to stay at a house that would accommodate my two dogs. This house fit the bill perfectly. It was clean and comfortable and my dogs loved exploring the path between the house and the creek. The traffic on the highway was more than I thought it would be, but I was very careful with my dogs while out walking, so it was fine."

Large, charming lake cottage nestled in the heart of our private lake community.

10/10 Excellent

"Summer after summer, Huckle Chuckle has been wonderfully comfortable and accommodating for our family vacations. It is bright and roomy for all of our activities, especially gatherings on the deck overlooking Eagles Mere lake. Located within walking distance of the lake to the north and the Eagles Mere shops to the south, we always have plenty to do. Trails and the Outlet Pond are always favorites, especially with easy access to Laurel Path around the lake.The occasional and rare concern we have had were immediately and personally addressed by the owners, leaving us confident that we were in good hands. We look forward to our 2027 summer 2027 at Huckle Chuckle."

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Convertible Car Rentals in Hughesville

Room 1

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Top Cities in Sullivan County

Eagles Mere

Our top choices for Sullivan County cottages

1. CREEKSIDE COTTAGE located on Route 87 close to the Loyalsock Creek.

2. Large, charming lake cottage nestled in the heart of our private lake community.

3. Muncy Vacation Rental w/ Deck & Views

4. The Katonah House at Lake Mokoma - Pet Friendly with Lake, Beach, & Boat Access.

5. Owl's Nest - Treehouse -2mi. from falls trailhead

6. Eagles Mere lakefront 6-bedroom 3-bath cottage

7. BullFrog cottage, Harveys Lake, PA - Spectacular lakefront presence and view!

8. "Timber Acres" is nestled in the woods with private pond in Eagles Mere

9. "Tranquility Cottage" is a quaint cottage on the West Side of Lake Mokoma

10. Deluxe Cabin G: 9 Mi to Worlds End State Park!

11. Benton Home on 50 Acres w/ Private Deck & Views!

12. Pennsylvania Abode Near Little League World Series

13. Hillsgrove Creekside Cabin: Close to Hiking

14. Pet-friendly Cabin w/ Grill in Hillsgrove

15. Lakefront wooden "Heritage House Cottage" in Lake Mokoma

16. Comfortable Muncy Home w/ Serene Views!

17. Spacious & Secluded Forksville Home: Fire Pit

18. "Southern Shores" on Lake Mokoma

19. Deluxe Cabin D at Elk Creek Escape! Pets Welcome

20. Waterfront New Albany Retreat w/ Therapy Animals

Find vacation rentals that suit your style

Top Sullivan County Hotel Reviews

Quality Inn Bloomsburg

Days Inn by Wyndham Williamsport

Super 8 by Wyndham Mifflinville Near Bloomsburg

Comfort Suites Bloomsburg

City Hall Grand Hotel

Holiday Inn Express Bloomsburg by IHG

Outdoorsman’s Paradise

Secluded Cabin in Great Location - Close to State Parks in the Endless Mountains

Large, charming lake cottage nestled in the heart of our private lake community.

Explore a world of travel with Expedia