Search Cottages in Montclair

"Was chaotic while checking in. The hotel definitely is not prepared to handle large crowds and the elevator system takes forever for a large number of requests. The rooms are good for NYC standards and the bar was nice."

"The room was clean and quiet. Breakfast was a plus. It was fresh and hot and well stocked. The staff was helpful and polite. Location was great. "

"I was very happy with my stay . They upgraded my room to a suite . The king bed was so comfortable. Maid was very nice. Because I was a solo traveller they included lunch at a nearby deli. Loved my stay ! Not first time at the Edison."

"We noticed no coffee or hot water in the rooms"

"Room is clean. Location is perfict, very convenient."

"Room was tiny. Food options were really poor and very expensive. Elevator upto front desk and to the rooms was hectic."

"Stayed in room 4012 and just the overall feel is outdated. My buddie was in 3909 and his tv stand Was falling apart. Elevator make so crazy sounds. Just old and outdated type of place"

"Loved my stay! The coffee shop, rooftop bar, club, all the amenities were wonderful. Hotel was beautiful, I went with the higher floor and did not regret it. Would book again and again."

"We always stay at the New Yorker when we are in New York, whether for business or for pleasure. The hotel is convenient for us for our business and for attending theatre and restaurants in the theatre district. The price is good for the value. The least expensive rooms are rather small; but some of their rooms are large with a refrigerator. The building is older but renovated. So it has the advantage of larger windows and high ceilings. Ask for corner rooms to get more windows. The staff is very friendly and helpful. And there are many restaurants and stores in easy walking distance."