Find all hotels by Independent in Plum Island, NJ
Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Tonight
23 Sep - 24 SepTomorrow
24 Sep - 25 SepThis weekend
25 Sep - 27 SepNext weekend
2 Oct - 4 Oct
Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in
Top Plum Island Hotel Reviews
PUBLIC, an Ian Schrager hotel
10/10 Excellent
"Staff were all really friendly and place and location was perfect."
Sela V Hotel
8/10 Good
"As a native New Yorker now living out of state, I was genuinely excited to try Sela V and experience a fresh addition to Brooklyn’s hotel scene. The property itself is stunning, thoughtfully designed, visually striking, and full of character. Many of the shared spaces made me feel like I was relaxing in a stylish studio loft rather than a traditional hotel, which I loved. That said, this stay is best suited for travelers who are flexible and already familiar with getting around the city. The immediate area doesn’t offer much in terms of attractions or walkable activities, so first‑time visitors may find it limiting. Service was the biggest miss. For a new Brooklyn hotel with such a beautiful and unique aesthetic, I expected a warmer, more welcoming staff experience. The bar and food options also weren’t clearly advertised, and it was often hard to tell whether they were open at all. The café space was pleasant but very limited. The room design is gorgeous, but a few functional details fell short, lighting, additional storage but particularly the shower setup. With no vent and full glass panels, the bathroom floor stayed wet, which isn’t ideal. Overall, Sela V is visually breathtaking and full of potential, but the service and surrounding neighborhood still need time to catch up to the design. I’d return for the aesthetic alone, but only with adjusted expectations."
West Village Eurohostel
10/10 Excellent
"."
The Washington
8/10 Good
"Hated the lobby, elevators were awkward, staff was unprofessional. Location was convenient. Price gouging for 9/11 families"
DoubleTree by Hilton Hotel Newark Airport
8/10 Good
"I did told her please bring towels but they didn't bring it. I won't eat breakfast because too expensive price no thank you but need free breakfast. Really? why they have to pay for parking daily so waste brokeomoney"
Arlo SoHo
10/10 Excellent
"Q"
Moxy NYC Chelsea
10/10 Excellent
"Checked in with Liz who is amazing thank you liz all staff were lovely and we had the best time will deffo be back :)"
Explore a world of travel with Expedia
- Hotels with Bars in Red Bank - Tinton Falls
- La Quinta Inn & Suites Hotels in Middletown
- Hostels in Middletown
- B&B in Monmouth Beach
- Apartments in Rumson
- 4 Star Hotels in Hazlet
- Hotels with smoking rooms in Red Bank - Tinton Falls
- Guest Houses in Keansburg
- Cottages in Sea Bright
- Hilton Hotels in Rumson
- Villas in Red Bank
- Hotels with Bars in Keansburg
- Extended Stay America Hotels in Keansburg
- 5 Star Hotels in Sea Bright
- Premier Inn Hotels in Oceanport
- La Quinta Inn & Suites Hotels in Red Bank
- Motels in Sea Bright
- Cottages in Atlantic Highlands
- Condo Rentals in Monmouth Beach
- Onefinestay Hotels in Middletown
- Hotels with a Pool in Middletown
- Historic Hotels in Long Branch
- Hilton Hotels in Middletown
- B&B in Sea Bright
- Motels in Keansburg
- 2 Star Hotels in Middletown
- 5 Star Hotels in Red Bank - Tinton Falls
- Marriott Hotels & Resorts in Red Bank
- Hotels near Count Basie Theater
- 5 Star Hotels in Monmouth Beach
- Vacation Homes in Hazlet
- Extended Stay America Hotels in Rumson
- Villas in Rumson
- Beach Hotels in Keansburg
- Onefinestay Hotels in Highlands
- Wyndham Hotels in Keansburg
- Oyo Rooms Hotels in Keansburg
- Resorts in Rumson
- 3 Star Hotels in Middletown
- Hyatt Hotels in Middletown
- Motels in Red Bank
- 2 Star Hotels in Highlands
- Condo Rentals in Hazlet
- Pet-Friendly Hotels in Long Branch
- Hilton Hotels in Atlantic Highlands
- Independent Hotels in Middletown
- Oyo Rooms Hotels in Atlantic Highlands
- B&B in Red Bank - Tinton Falls
- Hilton Hotels in Sea Bright
- Cottages in Rumson
- B&B in Keansburg
- 3 Star Hotels in Keansburg
- Red Roof Inn Hotels in Little Silver
- Hilton Hotels in Monmouth Beach
- Red Roof Inn Hotels in Atlantic Highlands
- Independent Hotels in Little Silver
- 2 Star Hotels in Atlantic Highlands
- Onefinestay Hotels in Leonardo
- Hotels with WiFi in Red Bank
- 4 Star Hotels in Middletown
- Pet-Friendly Hotels in Hazlet
- 2 Star Hotels in Hazlet
- 3 Star Hotels in Sea Bright
- 4 Star Hotels in Sea Bright
- Hotels near Two River Theater
- Business Hotels in Long Branch
- Motels in Atlantic Highlands
- Hyatt Hotels in Highlands
- Apartments in Hazlet
- Hotels with an Indoor Pool in Red Bank - Tinton Falls
- 5 Star Hotels in Little Silver
- La Quinta Inn & Suites Hotels in Rumson
- B&B in Red Bank
- Hotels with Hot Tubs in Red Bank
- Marriott Hotels & Resorts in Highlands
- Guest Houses in Sea Bright
- Pet-Friendly Hotels in Red Bank
- Boutique Hotels in Red Bank
- Best Western Hotels in Sea Bright
- 4 Star Hotels in Highlands
- Best Western Hotels in Keansburg
- Marriott Hotels & Resorts in Keansburg
- Hotels near PNC Bank Art Center
- Luxury Hotels in Long Branch
- Wyndham Hotels in Rumson
- Vacation Homes in Middletown
- Cottages in Keansburg
- Resorts in Oceanport
- Houseboats in Rumson
- Hotusa Hotels in Keansburg