Find Beach Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, NY

Shelter Island Heights and its attractions for beach lovers

Nestled on the serene shores of Shelter Island Heights, New York, travelers with a love for the beach will find a slice of paradise. Start your day at Crescent Beach, known for its soft white sands and gentle waves, perfect for families looking to enjoy a fun-filled day under the sun. For a unique experience, visit the nearby Sunset Beach, where you can savor delicious seafood while watching the stunning sunset over the water. Take a leisurely stroll along the picturesque Shelter Island Heights Harbor, where you can rent kayaks or paddleboards to explore the tranquil waters at your own pace. Don’t miss a visit to the historic Shelter Island Country Club, where you can enjoy a round of golf or tennis with views of the surrounding landscape. As you explore this charming area, consider staying at one of the boutique hotels that offer easy access to these beaches, providing attentive service and comfortable accommodations that make you feel pampered. After a day of adventure, retreat to your hotel and unwind, knowing that you are just steps away from the sandy shores and all the beach activities that await.

Find the best beach hotels and resorts in Shelter Island Heights

For those seeking a beach getaway in Shelter Island Heights, these hotels offer the perfect blend of sun, sand, and comfort. Each hotel boasts excellent beach amenities and a relaxing atmosphere for travelers looking to unwind by the water.

The Pridwin Hotel

• Why it's great for the ultimate beach vacation spot: The Pridwin Hotel is an exceptional choice for travelers looking to indulge in a beachside retreat. With a remarkable review rating of 9.6, this hotel features direct beach access and offers guests a private sandy beach, ensuring a serene escape. Travelers can enjoy beach sun loungers and umbrellas while soaking up the sun or take in the beautiful views from the ocean-view restaurant.
• Other amenities: Beyond its beach offerings, The Pridwin Hotel boasts a stunning terrace and spa services including hydrotherapy treatments and Swedish massages to rejuvenate guests. With a lovely pool, fitness facilities, and daily breakfast included, guests will find comfort and leisure in every corner. The hotel also features complimentary ferry terminal shuttle service and daily housekeeping for added convenience.
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 0.07 miles, Sunset Beach - 0.54 miles, Shelter Island Whale's Tail - 2.46 miles

House on Chase Creek

• Why it's great for the ultimate beach vacation spot: Offering a cozy and inviting atmosphere, House on Chase Creek is perfect for travelers looking for a budget-friendly beach escape. With a review rating of 9.4, this charming hotel is just a short distance from the nearby beach, making it an ideal spot for beach enthusiasts who want to enjoy the sun without breaking the bank.
• Other amenities: Guests can unwind on the terrace or patio, and enjoy the warmth of a fireplace in the evenings. The hotel offers free toiletries, self-parking, and convenient access to nearby golf courses for those looking to hit the greens. With its relaxing ambiance, House on Chase Creek promises a delightful stay on Shelter Island Heights.
• Neighborhood: The Heights
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 1.3 miles, Sunset Beach - 1.18 miles, Shelter Island Country Club - 0.54 miles

The Chequit

• Why it's great for the ultimate beach vacation spot: The Chequit is a wonderful choice for travelers seeking a boutique-style beach getaway. With a review rating of 8.8, this hotel is conveniently located near the beach, giving guests easy access to the shoreline for sunbathing or relaxing walks along the coast.
• Other amenities: Guests at The Chequit can enjoy premium bedding, free self-parking, and a welcoming atmosphere. The hotel also offers lovely gardens for a peaceful retreat and is pet-friendly for those bringing along a furry companion. With its charming design and nearby the beach, The Chequit is a delightful option for a memorable stay.
• Neighborhood: The Heights
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 1.37 miles, Sunset Beach - 1.12 miles, Shelter Island Country Club - 0.54 miles

Shelter Island House

• Why it's great for the ultimate beach vacation spot: Shelter Island House stands out as a great option for beach lovers, showcasing a solid review rating of 8.4. Located near the beach, this hotel allows guests to easily access the sandy shores and enjoy a leisurely day by the water.
• Other amenities: The hotel features a lovely terrace, complimentary breakfast options, and convenient self-parking. Guests can also take advantage of the premium rooms with kitchen facilities, making it easy to prepare meals during their stay. With nearby golf courses and delightful gardens, Shelter Island House offers a charming retreat for travelers looking to enjoy the beach and local attractions.
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 0.52 miles, Sunset Beach - 0.39 miles, Shelter Island Whale's Tail - 1.7 miles

West Neck Guesthouse

• Why it's great for the ultimate beach vacation spot: Ideal for budget-conscious travelers, West Neck Guesthouse provides a comfortable and inviting atmosphere with a review rating of 8.2. Located close to the beach, this guesthouse allows guests to easily explore the sandy shores and enjoy a day of relaxation.
• Other amenities: The hotel features a kitchenette for convenient meal preparation, complimentary breakfast options, and a lovely garden to unwind in. Guests can also take advantage of free self-parking and daily housekeeping for a straightforward experience. With its laid-back vibe and nearby the beach, West Neck Guesthouse is perfect for those looking to enjoy Shelter Island Heights.
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 0.7 miles, Sunset Beach - 0.57 miles, Shelter Island Whale's Tail - 1.35 miles