Find Adventure Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, NY

"Perfect place- great amenities- beautiful room!"

"Delightful property and even more delightful staff. love staying here! "

"Cute apartment in a house, separate from the hosts space downstairs. Clean and walking distance to some great harbor-front restaurants. 1 bed and 2 couches (no pull-out couch)"

"The place was adorable and spotless, the beds were super comfortable it was perfect and a minute from the beach! We will be back. Thanks for a great time!"

"Gina was such a lovely host and ensured our stay was perfect. The house was spotless and had everything we needed. The property was very relaxing outside with a lovely warm pool. It was a lovely stay and in a great location. Thank you Gina."

"charming historic property, ideal for large groups."

"We had the best time! The house was great and the little bay was wonderful for exploring and swimming. Our kids spent every day splashing and trying to catch stuff with their nets. The area is so nice and peaceful. The host was very friendly and responsive. "