Search Motels in Tingler Island

"The rooms could use a little TLC. Fresh paint, new shower heads, new fridge. That said, so could everywhere in the Keys. But what this place offered outshines that. The peace and quiet of being the only spot on the island. The dock right outside the back sliding glass door. The sunset and sunrise views. The escape. I loved my stay here and wish I had gotten to stay longer. "

"Staff was very pleasant (even apologetic for the cooler than usual temperature!). Rooms were a bit dated but the overall quality of our stay was very good."

"Good"

"Great staff and good location with good restaurants nearby"

"Room was good. Clean and facing the water. The bar down stairs was unexpected but good. "

"The rooms were very clean and the staff was amazing. The restaurant was absolutely wonderful. The staff there was fantastic and the food was fabulous!!!"

"YES & YES— clean room, amenities & well kept property. Staff, especially Otis. More should be done to redirect, reorient unfamiliar guests from the front desk at number 1996 near the public street to the back of the property where check in and registration occurs."

"clean and nice"

"The staff was very helpful and friendly. The location is great and it has nice amenities, kayaks, breakfast, pool etc. Would definitely recommend it to others."