Find Hotels with Bars in Fire Island, NY

"Would rate the property 3+/4-. Carpet and curtain stains, peeling paint were eyesores. Room blinds would not release to cover the window and the window curtains had to be propped with a cushion to approximate closure. Limited in-room coffee. Friendly, attentive staff. Mixed reviews for King Bar and the Marketplace."

"The air conditioning wouldn't turn off, we froze in the room all night. We were told it was a new system and some rooms had problems The toilet ran all the time and the room next to us was very loud late into the night. We got very little sleep and no effort was made at any time to put us in a different room even after we complained about these multiple issues. Sophie at the bar was great as was Wayne the security guy. Hotel was clean, it just wasn't an enjoyable stay."

"I had a great weekend. Staff was friendly and I thought the premises looked really nice."

"Entry area is run down, as is the rest of the areas I walked through. The room had not been vacuumed. The mattress was sunken."

"The room smells like homelessness no judging but that’s not how I want to be welcomed to a room. I kept the AC so it could keep a fresh smell but it didn’t work all I got was a small cold. If you want temporary short term stay it does the job but if you’re staying for leisure this isn’t the place. "

"Awesome stay and accommodations"

"The room was clean and there was plenty of towels. It was comfortable to sleep in. The area was also quiet. "

"They gave me a pet room, i requested a handicapped friendly room. After we settled in I noticed a strong urine smell from the carpet. We were too tired to repack and request a room change. Suffered through the odor. The rooms need renovation, staff was fine."

"Better than expected. Spacious clean room"