"A very average experience for the money paid."

"A classic, old-timey hotel. Extremely kind and helpful staff. Very clean. Cannot get more convenient to MSG, Apollo and Liberty Bagels, and Penn Station. If you are looking for something super updated, you may want to try another property, but I was personally charmed by the New Yorker."

"The staff is nice and the room was clean. The biggest issues we had were cold showers at any given time and the air conditioning not working. Now we did not bring these issues up to staff- the weather was nice enough we were able to just buy a fan and go on about our day. There was also not a refrigerator or microwave in the room- as someone who’s never been to New York before, this may be entirely normal but it was a shock for us- so I’m at least putting it out there. The location was...