"My husband and I were looking for a quiet escape, and this charming cottage on Lake Erie delivered in every way. The lake views alone are worth the stay. We couldn't stop staring at the water from the moment we arrived.The space is clean, cozy, and thoughtfully put together. Comfy beds and pillows. The updated bathroom was a nice surprise, and the kitchen had everything we needed!Our favorite moment? Sitting by the fire pit at sunset with our two Yorkies, watching the sky turn pink and orange...
"My husband and I were looking for a quiet escape, and this charming cottage on Lake Erie delivered in every way. The lake views alone are worth the stay. We couldn't stop staring at the water from the moment we arrived.The space is clean, cozy, and thoughtfully put together. Comfy beds and pillows. The updated bathroom was a nice surprise, and the kitchen had everything we needed!Our favorite moment? Sitting by the fire pit at sunset with our two Yorkies, watching the sky turn pink and orange...
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Book a reading with a certified medium at this spiritualist community where the veil between worlds feels thinnest. Join daily workshops at Inspiration Stump or take a healing energy walk along the peaceful lakeside paths.
Such a cool place to stay. Clean, comfortable, quiet and unique rooms. It is such a nice break from standard hotel rooms. The staff is always friendly and the location is perfectly located in town,
Such a cool place to stay. Clean, comfortable, quiet and unique rooms. It is such a nice break from standard hotel rooms. The staff is always friendly and the location is perfectly located in town,
Scott
Reviewed November 2, 2026Reviewed November 2, 2026
More Handicap parking closer to entrance would be nicer. The staff saw me struggling to walk with my cane so a employee ran over with a wheel chair and took me all the way to our room and said we can keep it till we check out. She also went back and found the foot pads for the chair which made it easier to elevate the legs. Also I checked the second day of our stay and asked if I could take the chair with us to see some family in the area and he checked and said ok which was a great help as I...
More Handicap parking closer to entrance would be nicer. The staff saw me struggling to walk with my cane so a employee ran over with a wheel chair and took me all the way to our room and said we can keep it till we check out. She also went back and found the foot pads for the chair which made it easier to elevate the legs. Also I checked the second day of our stay and asked if I could take the chair with us to see some family in the area and he checked and said ok which was a great help as I...
We had the pleasure of staying in this hotel on two separate occasions this past July. It was so wonderful on our first trip; there was no question where we'd stay when we returned to Jamestown. You can still smell the "newness" of the hotel in each room. The rooms had impressive new furnishings and were very spacious - we booked a double bed room and suite with a sofa bed, microwave, and small bar sink. The beds were super comfy and the bathrooms were immaculately clean. Free breakfast in the...
We had the pleasure of staying in this hotel on two separate occasions this past July. It was so wonderful on our first trip; there was no question where we'd stay when we returned to Jamestown. You can still smell the "newness" of the hotel in each room. The rooms had impressive new furnishings and were very spacious - we booked a double bed room and suite with a sofa bed, microwave, and small bar sink. The beds were super comfy and the bathrooms were immaculately clean. Free breakfast in the...
The Theater Motel was built in a different era and shows its wear and tear. When I arrived the host and her very cheerful toddler greeted me. The bed was new, the room, linens and bathroom were clean. The room had a slight musty smell but well within expectations. Many chain hotels could take a hint from these hosts’ efforts in providing a pleasant experience. They are working towards improvements and deserve the support of budget minded travelers.
The Theater Motel was built in a different era and shows its wear and tear. When I arrived the host and her very cheerful toddler greeted me. The bed was new, the room, linens and bathroom were clean. The room had a slight musty smell but well within expectations. Many chain hotels could take a hint from these hosts’ efforts in providing a pleasant experience. They are working towards improvements and deserve the support of budget minded travelers.
Steve
Reviewed September 30, 2015Reviewed September 30, 2015
It was a good stay. Staff are pleasant and have a desire to serve. A new brewery is on its way. The included breakfast was complete…hot upscale continental. Shout out to banquet server Karen O.
It was a good stay. Staff are pleasant and have a desire to serve. A new brewery is on its way. The included breakfast was complete…hot upscale continental. Shout out to banquet server Karen O.
I came here with my littlest girl for a few days. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. Our room was clean and everything worked as it should. The bed was comfortable with lots of pillows, great for an end of day pillow fight before going to sleep at night! We will be back next year. Thanks!
I came here with my littlest girl for a few days. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. Our room was clean and everything worked as it should. The bed was comfortable with lots of pillows, great for an end of day pillow fight before going to sleep at night! We will be back next year. Thanks!
We think that a vacation should be a walk in the park, so if you're chasing cottages in Lily Dale at a competitive rate, Expedia delivers. Keep costs down and opt for an inexpensive option surrounded by nature, or splurge on a luxury cottage to really spoil your favorite people.
How can I find cheap cottages in Lily Dale?
Expedia is here to help you look for cheap cottages in Lily Dale. To discover a fantastic stay in a few clicks, use our handy filter tool to refine your search by amenities, budget and star rating.