Find all hotels by Budget Host in Shelter Island Heights, NY

"Breakfast and the Halyard restaurant are top shelf. A few quirks with our room(s) - no cable service, a locked bathroom door that couldn’t be opened, and a dead bolt that didn’t work- but the staff were helpful and accommodating and did everything they could to make things right."

"The bed was so comfortable. Loved the complimentary coffee and pastries. "

"Breakfast had a nice variety from Waffles that came out perfect to pantries fresh fruit and the place was clean! And fresh smelling."

"Beautiful hotel in the marine. CT summer playground. "

"My husband and I stayed for one night at Montauk Blue. The room was very clean, comfortable bed, and stunning view of the ocean. Staff was extremely nice. Didn't swim in the pool, but we wanted to look at the pool room. The pool was extremely clean and inviting. Next time, we will try the jacuzzi. The hotel is a 2 block walk to Main Street. Ate dinner at Shagwong. Everything was great. Will be back."

"Overall the places is nice, clean and great views"

"Easy parking "

"Very nice staff, amenities great, an older place, but well kept. Wish there was more than 1 window, a bit stuffy. Felt safe in parking lot and in my room."

"This is my second stay at this hotel, I recommend it."