Top Cabin Rentals in Town of Italy in 2026

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks

In two months

In three months

In four months

Our top choices for Town of Italy cabin rentals

A two-story log cabin with a green door and windows, surrounded by trees and a gravel driveway.

1. Timber Haven - Serene getaway-Fireplace, air conditioning, fire pit, grill, WiFi

Cohocton

Mike F.

AED 893 total

includes taxes & fees

14 Oct - 15 Oct

A backyard with two small sheds, a firewood stack, and string lights.

2. Charming Cabin minutes from Keuka Lake

Bath

Erez

A small wooden shed with a white door, a window, and a small porch area with plants.

3. Seneca Hideaway/Sunken Vessel/Hot Tub

Geneva

Nujhat I.

A single-story blue house with a porch, a small attached garage, and a grassy yard.

4. Cozy, rustic cabin with beautiful views, privacy and 1 mile from Keuka Lake

PennYan

Karen H.

AED 823 total

includes taxes & fees

12 Oct - 13 Oct

A building with large windows and a sign that reads "ginger coffee."

5. THE GRAPE ESCAPE - PET FRIENDLY! - OFF GRID - ROMANTIC LAKE VIEW - ON WINE TRAIL

Hammondsport

martine d.

A wooden cabin with a porch, surrounded by a garden and a forest.

6. Vacation Rental Cabin, Keuka Lake Outlet-Trail, Wine Trail. Brand New in 2016

Penn Yan

Alissa

A cozy log cabin interior with a wooden ceiling, a stone fireplace, leather furniture, and large windows offering natural light.

7. Luxurious Log Cabin in Woods on Keuka Lake w Prvt Dock & Lake Front

pulteney

Margaret C.

A cozy living room with a stone fireplace, wooden furniture, and deer antlers on the wall.

8. WELCOME! WE ARE PET FRIENDLY.

Keuka Park

Christa G.

A rustic cabin with a porch, a window, and a star decoration.

9. STARWOOD - PET FRIENDLY! - OFF GRID - ROMANTIC - ON WINE TRAIL

Hammondsport

Katherine L. S.

A rustic log cabin with a wooden deck and a stone pathway leading to the entrance.

10. Cozy Country Cabin near Canandaigua-HOT TUB-Seasonally Decorated-Sunsets-CMAC

Rushville

HHSA H.

A tree with a sign reading "3024" in a grassy area with a building in the background.

11. Recently Renovated 3 BR Jewel in the Heart of Finger Lakes

Branchport

Steven U.

A single-story building with a metal roof, a front staircase, and a flagpole.

12. Newly Renovated Rustic Cabin w/WiFi in the Heart of the Finger Lakes

Branchport

"Upon arrival we found a clean, peaceful property with a well equipped kitchen and a comfortable living room and bedroom. The entrance foyer and sitting/dining area was warm and inviting. Outside we discovered a comfortable campfire area with a walking space including a small pond. Each evening we were serenaded by frogs and insects into a soothing sleep. We were awakened gently by cool air and sunshine. Penn Yan has a general store which we visited on the way down, providing all of our...

Jack S

A cozy outdoor seating area with a fire pit, two red Adirondack chairs, and a wooden cabin with large windows.

13. FROG HOUSE - PET FRIENDLY! - OFF GRID - ROMANTIC WINE TRAIL CABIN - Year Round.

Prattsburgh

Andrew B.

A small, single-story building with a white exterior and a brown roof, surrounded by a well-maintained lawn and flower beds.

14. Beautiful Tiny home Near The Lake

Canandaigua

Melody O.

AED 292 total

includes taxes & fees

14 Oct - 15 Oct

A brown wooden building with two large windows and a door, surrounded by gravel and trees.

15. Seneca Hideaway/Rustic Hunter’s cabin/Hot Tub

Geneva

"This was such a perfect extended weekend stay! The cabins were cozy and had everything we needed. This is great for small groups who want their own spaces but still have the ability to do things as a group. There are 2 cabins super close to eachother and 1 that is off a bit on its own overlooking the pond. This was a perfect location for exploring Seneca Lake and Watkins Glen! As the icing on the cake, our trip ended with a surprise proposal at the Belhurst Castle i highly recommend and look...

Jourdan M.