Find all hotels by Independent in Island Park, NY

"Great location and near everything I needed."

"Very clean room, which is important. But people should know this is a very, very bad neighborhood so not for the faint of heart . . ."

"Parking is available but scarce. You could end up with having to park on the streets if you check-in late. There is no clear parking regulations or enforcement. Vehicles were just parked anywhere on the property. The room was clean and equipped with everything needed to spend the night. The water supply pipes were loud when taps were turned on and silent when turned off. Neighbour’s included. This woke me up in the middle of the night. Overall this hotel was very good for the price. I recommend it to anybody wanting to stay in NYC by the LaGuardia Airport."

"The hotel was clean and the breakfast options were typical Holiday Inn Express type foods. The staff could have been more helpful. The shuttle runs until 9pm. You call the hotel and request pick up from the train station. One night we called multiple times for shuttle service and ended up paying for Lyft because no one would answer the desk and yes, there was someone there when we returned."

"Clean room, but microwave and floor was dirty "

"Smells not good"

"Great hotel with great amenities in a beautiful part of the city."

"I loved the location of this hotel, It was a few doors down from the grocery store, bars and restaurants. The staff was very nice and polite. I would definitely stay here again. The only thing I would do different is book a room that has the shower that is not in with the toliet."

"Truly welcoming and helpful staff. Exceptional, moderately priced hotel well situated to get anywhere in Brooklyn or Manhattan (both L and G lines right outside door of hotel)."